On the plus side, Arthur Christmas does come from Englands Aardman Animation who have a sterling reputation for their work in Claymation, beginning in the 1980s with the classic Wallace and Gromit shorts A Grand Day Out (1989), The Wrong Trousers (1993) and A Close Shave (1995). The success of these and other works allowed Aardman to expand out onto cinema screens in the 00s with Chicken Run (2000) and Wallace & Gromit in The Curse of the Were-Rabbit (2005). Starting with Flushed Away (2006), Aardman sacrificed Claymation for standard 2D computer-drawn animation. This is clearly a commercial move with computer-drawn animation being far less costly and time-consuming than having to animate three-dimensional clay models one frame at a time. Indeed, with Arthur Christmas, the majority of the animation chores have been handed over to Sony Pictures Animation, the US-based studio that also made Open Season (2006), Surfs Up (2007), Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs (2009), Hotel Transylvania (2012) and The Emoji Movie (2017). With the subsequent The Pirates! Band of Misfits (2012), Aardman took the path of combining both computer-drawn animation and Claymation but did make a turn to regular stop-motion animation with Shaun the Sheep Movie (2015).
All of that said, I enjoyed Arthur Christmas a good deal more than any of the above listed reasons would have led me to expect. The plot of Santas sibling or son/daughter having to prove themselves in the eye of the old man is one that has served a good many other Christmas films see the insipid likes of Single Santa Seeks Mrs. Claus (2004), Santa and Sons & Daughter! (2005), Santa Baby (2006) and Fred Claus (2007) but Arthur Christmas still manages to get surprising mileage out of it. The film starts to win you over from its opening scenes where Arthur receives a card from Gwen asking vexatious logical questions about Santa and the North Pole how so many presents are delivered to all the houses of the world over one night, or If you live at the North Pole, how come I dont see you on Google Earth? The scenes with Stephen and the army of elves going into operation commando-styled to deliver the presents en masse are a positively hilarious playing out of the answers to these questions.
Flushed Away was a relative disappointment for Aardman, where their distinctive humour seemed to disappear inside the machinery of the formula animated film. The good news is that this emerges far more successfully in Arthur Christmas. It comes with a sparkly wit and remembers to bring back the characteristically oddball and distinctly British characters that inhabit Aardmans Wallace and Gromit shorts. There is an appealing eccentricity that runs through the film running gags about a stolen brass mock reindeer, Arthurs light-up fluffy Christmas slippers and especially about Bryonys wrapping skills. At one point, the film sports the appealingly surreal image of elephants, lions and zebras all rising up into the air off the African veldt after being sprinkled with magic dust. Director Sarah Smith, previously a British tv comedy producer, most notably with the tv series The League of Gentlemen (1999-2002), packs an enormous creativity and energy into every corner of the film. Moreover, the themes that the film champions of the unassuming underdog winning out over the anonymous mass efficiency process, the belief that everybody counts, the importance of tradition, of Arthur finally being accepted by his father are delivered in heart-warming ways without the film ever managing a misstep into the mawkish feelgood sentimentality of most other Christmas films.
The film boasts an amazing voice cast. James McAvoy makes for a perfect Arthur, while the unmistakeable tones of Hugh Laurie come through as the pompously clipped Steve. Bill Nighy has a great deal of fun sinking his teeth into the role of Grandsanta, while Imelda Staunton makes a perfectly proper and matter-of-fact Mrs Santa. That said, the winning voice performance comes from Ashley Jensen, probably better known as the female lead and unrequited love interest in Ricky Gervaiss Extras (2005-7), whose Scottish wrapping elf manages to steal the entire film.