Robin Williams had long been rumoured to be cast in the part of The Riddler. However, one had a sinking feeling about Batman Forever from the moment they learned that Robin Williams had been dropped in favour of then flavour of the moment Jim Carrey, the facially hyperkinetic actor who had just come from the huge box-office success of the likes of Ace Ventura: Pet Detective (1994), The Mask (1994) and Dumb and Dumber (1994). Between them, Jim Carrey and Tommy Lee Jones, who is usually capable of great things he had just won a well-deserved Oscar for The Fugitive (1993) run unrestrained though the film in two performances that only astound by their loudness and the epic awfulness of their overacting. Am I being over-the-top? Its hard to tell, yells Carrey at one point, in the films most unwittingly damning line.
The two previous Batman films certainly allowed people like Jack Nicholson and Danny DeVito opportunity for similar all-stops-pulled overacting but at the same time tightly constrained their performances within the dark psychology of the characters. Not so Batman Forever. It was the ability to get behind the masks and clown faces and see the villains in psychological terms that made the first two films so darkly captivating. Batman Forever demonstrates no understanding of that and the villains here lack any psychological depth at all, despite the presence of a character who is supposed to be a criminal psychologist. The script even manages to completely omit the crucial idiosyncrasies that the two villains had in the comic-book Two-Faces schizoid moral split between giving into his twisted side or his good side, as decided by the flipping of his two-headed coin; and The Riddlers psychological dependence on riddles that tip Batman and the authorities off to where he is going to strike. Without any dimension to the villains, Jim Carrey and Tommy Lee Jones are just lunatics in silly costumes. Indeed, the Batman (1992-4) animated tv series that came out at the same time invented far more psychologically compelling origins for both villains than Batman Forever does. In fact, Batman Forever ends up resembling no more than a horridly overbudgeted episode of the Batman (1966-8) tv series with its campy scenery-chewing guest appearances from well-known actors of the day. This is something that would reach its zenith with director Joel Schumachers subsequent entry in the series, the astoundingly bad Batman & Robin (1997). It was fairly much regarded that Joel Schumacher killed the Batman franchise off after this point and it took nearly an entire decade before Christopher Nolan could bring it back to strength with Batman Begins (2005), The Dark Knight (2008) and The Dark Knight Rises (2012), as well as producing Batman V Superman: Dawn of Justice (2016).
Heartthrob Val Kilmer is badly miscast as Batman. For a start, Val Kilmer seems only about thirty. When it comes to the introduction of Robin, Kilmer is simply not the right age to play mentor the relationship seems more one of equals than, as it has always traditionally been, of the older man to his younger ward. The part has clearly been written with Michael Keaton, who was in his forties and exactly the right age, in mind. Nor has Val Kilmer ever been what one would exactly call an expressive performer and the part seems to have simplified for his limited acting range gone is all the twitchy nervousness and moral indecision in Keatons portrayal. Nicole Kidman has no other point in the film than to be the love interest. At least, Michael Gough gives Alfred the best airing of all the four films, at last bringing out the characters customary dry wit.
The single piece of characterization that the entire sorry farrago does get right is the Robin origin. Robin was always an annoyance in the original comics he was too obviously an attempt to add kiddie appeal. However, Batman Forever succeeds in assimilating him into the movie series Dark Knight milieu with conviction, giving him his own battle between light and darkness. Chris ODonnell contrives to make Robin a convincingly typical teen, rather than the usual fawning adolescent amusingly enough, his immediate response to finding the Batcave is to hotwire the Batmobile and go looking to pick up girls.
Batman Forevers greatest mistake was to replace Tim Burton with Joel Schumacher as director. Joel Schumacher is possibly the worst director to have ever been allowed loose on a multi-million dollar budgeted film (although he gets stiff competition from people like Renny Harlin, Michael Bay and Stephen Sommers). Schumacher, in films like The Lost Boys (1987) and Flatliners (1990), has proven himself a visually stylish director although very much a director of mood as opposed to substance. Joel Schumacher invests Batman Forever with much visual style but the plot is hopelessly empty-headed and one that reveals Schumacher as no more than an MTV director full of flash and theatrics and zero in the way of substance.
The film seems to be trying to overcompensate for the lack of both Michael Keaton and Tim Burton by the very busyness of its story, as though by keeping the audience involved they will not notice these deficits. It is an incredibly crowded story with running subplots that include two super-villains, the introduction of Robin, a new love interest, plus more unresolved psychological issues from Batmans past. The motif of psychological splits that ran through the previous two films is here upped to absurd extremes. Everyone seems psychologically split between morality and darkness Two-Face naturally; Dick/Robin between revenge and morality; Chase Meridian between her love for Bruce Wayne or the wrong man; Batman, in a poorly developed piece of motivation, over whether he should continue to fight crime any longer. The very busyness of the plot naturally tends to grant some of these elements scanty development one never gets to work out what the flashbacks to Bruces childhood are meant to be about, for instance. In the absurdly packed number of character stories running through the plot, the film well could have done with one super-villain less Two-Face is superfluous as a character, he could have been replaced by a standard crime kingpin without any discernible difference.
There are also times when the plot descends to moments of amazing silliness. The scene where Batman deduces that the numbers left in The Riddlers riddles represent an alpha-numeric code that spells the word Mystery and can be homophonically read as Mr E and therefore refers to Mr E(dward Nygma) is a piece of deductive reasoning that is mind-boggling in its leaps of intuitive logic. The previous Batman films always made nominal attempts to contain their Bat-acrobatics and action within the realms of plausibility but Batman Forever throws any semblance of this out the window having Batman making leaps from the tops of buildings to the ground without even the benefit of the usual Bat ropes or parafoils; the Batmobile being able to vertically scale walls when caught in a cul-de-sac; and in the opening moments, a huge steel vault being able to be swung back into its place while attached solely to a Batarang.
The sets throughout are particularly stunning. A new Batcave; a circus with huge threatening Gothic gargoyles inside the tent; streets that seem like the previous films dark city gone Japanese neon and all laid out on a series of wonderfully packed and cramped multi-levels; street gangs in striking UV paint; Two-Faces hideout, which comes in dual colours, split down the centre of the room, one side in rich white and the other in dangerous black; The Riddlers vast amphitheatre a colossal tower where the climactic fight takes place aboard a descending booby-trapped chandelier of sorts. Alas, while Tim Burtons Batman films seemed like they were taking place in a darkly urgent Gothic comic-book world; Joel Schumachers Batman films by comparison seem to be take place in merely a flashy nightclub.
Joel Schumachers other films of genre interest are: The Incredible Shrinking Woman (1981), the teen vampire film The Lost Boys (1987), the afterlife film Flatliners (1990), Batman & Robin (1997), the offensively redneck psycho film Falling Down (1993), the snuff movie thriller 8MM (1999), the psycho-thriller Phone Booth (2002), the musical adaptation of The Phantom of the Opera (2004), The Number 23 (2007) with a numerologically obsessed Jim Carrey and Town Creek (2009) about a Nazi vampire. Schumacher also wrote The Wiz (1978), a musical modernization of The Wizard of Oz (1939).
The other Batman films and tv series are:- Batman (1943) and Batman and Robin (1949), two 15-chapter serials from Columbia; the campy tv series Batman (1966-8) starring Adam West and Burt Ward, which produced one film spin-off with Batman (1966); the animated tv series The New Adventures of Batman (1977-8); the excellent animated series Batman (1992-4) inspired by the Tim Burton films and its follow-up The New Batman Adventures (1997-9), which spawned several film spin-offs with Batman: Mask of the Phantasm (1993), Batman and Mr Freeze: SubZero (1998), The Batman Superman Movie: Worlds Finest (1998) and Batman: Mystery of the Batwoman (2003), as well as the later DC Universe Original Animated Movies Superman/Batman: Public Enemies (2009), Batman: Under the Red Hood (2010), Superman/Batman: Apocalypse (2010), Batman: Year One (2011), Batman: The Dark Knight Returns Part I (2012), Batman: The Dark Knight Returns Part II (2013), Batman: Assault on Arkham (2014), Son of Batman (2014), Batman vs. Robin (2015), Batman: Bad Blood (2016), Batman: The Killing Joke (2016) and Batman and Harley Quinn (2017), as well as Batman: Gotham Knight (2008), a compilation of anime Batman shorts; Batman Beyond/Batman of the Future (1999-2001), the futuristic follow-up series from the same creative team featuring an aging Bruce Wayne and his young apprentice, which also spun off one animated film Batman Beyond: Return of the Joker (2000) and a tv series Static Shock (2000-4), which featured several appearances from Batman; the animated series The Batman (2004-8), which badly revised the basics of the series and was also spun off into a film with The Batman vs. Dracula (2005); two further animated series Batman: The Brave and the Bold (2008-11), which placed Batman alongside other DC superheroes, and Beware the Batman (2013-4); the live-action tv series Gotham (2014 ), which tells the origin stories of the familiar characters and villains as Bruce Wayne grows up; Batman turns up as an animated character in The Lego Movie (2014) and gets a whole film to himself in The Lego Batman Movie (2017); the animated films Batman Unlimited: Animal Instincts (2015) and Batman Unlimited: Monster Mayhem (2015) spun off from a line of action figures; and the animated Batman: Return of the Caped Crusaders (2016) and Batman vs. Two-Face (2017) featuring a return of Adam West and Burt Ward. Batman also makes appearances in the line-up of superheroes in various other DC-related animated series such as SuperFriends (1973-7), The All New SuperFriends Hour (1977-9) and Justice League/Justice League Unlimited (2001-5), as well as the films Justice League: The New Frontier (2008), Justice League: Crisis on Two Earths (2010), Justice League: Doom (2012), Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox (2013), Justice League: War (2014), Justice League: Throne of Atlantis (2015), Justice League: Gods and Monsters (2015), Justice League vs Teen Titans (2016) and Justice League Dark (2017). Other spin-offs include the short-lived live-action tv series Birds of Prey (2002), featuring the women of Batman a paraplegic Batgirl, Cat Womans daughter and Harley Quinn and the Halle Berry starring Catwoman (2004), while Robin appears as a member of Young Justice (2010-3) and Suicide Squad (2016) features a team-up of DC villains including The Joker and Harley Quinn. The Batman-Robin relationship is also excrutiatingly spoofed in the Superhero Speed Dating segment of Movie 43 (2013). Also of interest is Batman & Bill (2017), a documentary about the unacknowledged co-creator of Batman, Bill Finger.
(Nominee for Best Cinematography and Best Production Design at this sites Best of 1995 Awards).