The series was likeable in its banal and formulaic way (it, for example, rarely ever strayed outside of the living room of the Stevens home). Part of the shows appeal was undeniably its central characters. The appealingly sexy Elizabeth Montgomery seemed to play in a state of perpetual panic with eyes wide agog (although apparently Elizabeth Montgomery hated the role and wanted to leave throughout after the series ended, she refused to ever do the nose twinkle in public and spent the rest of her career up unto her death in 1995 playing serious dramatic roles at 180 degrees remove). Dick York played full of contorted OTT grimaces in any other series, he would be the pratfalling anal-retentive bureaucrat. And then there was Agnes Moorehead (who was nominated six times for an Emmy for her role, one more than Elizabeth Montgomery was) who played Endora while seeming to channel Bette Davis in full-blown camp flight. The show was later spun off as an animated series Tabitha and Adam and the Clown Family (1972) from Hanna-Barbera featuring the two children from the show, and the live-action Tabitha (1977) starring Lisa Hartman as the now grown-up daughter, although this only lasted twelve episodes.
Here Bewitched becomes another tv series of the 1960s/70s to be resurrected up on the big screen, joining the likes of The Addams Family (1991), The Beverly Hillbillies (1993), The Flintstones (1994), Mission: Impossible (1996), The Avengers (1998), Lost in Space (1998), Dudley Do-Right (1999), The Mod Squad (1999), My Favorite Martian (1999), Wild Wild West (1999), Charlies Angels (2000), I Spy (2002), Scooby-Doo (2002), Starsky & Hutch (2004), Thunderbirds (2004), The Dukes of Hazzard (2005), Miami Vice (2006), Transformers (2007), Get Smart (2008), Speed Racer (2008), Land of the Lost (2009), Star Trek (2009), The A-Team (2010), Yogi Bear (2010), The Smurfs (2011), Dark Shadows (2012), The Sweeney (2012), 21 Jump Street (2012), The Equalizer (2014), Jem and the Holograms (2015), The Man from U.N.C.L.E. (2015), Dads Army (2016), Baywatch (2017) and CHiPs (2017). The idea of remaking Bewitched has been around for at least ten years, with director Penny Marshall, who stays on as producer here, having at one point planned a version with Meryl Streep as Samantha and Barry Humphries!!!! as Endora.
Bewitched finally emerged in 2005 under the hands of Nora Ephron. Nora Ephron is a former screenwriter having been Academy Award nominated for her scripts for Silkwood (1983) and When Harry Met Sally ... (1989). After becoming a director, Ephron had a huge hit with her second film the romance Sleepless in Seattle (1993) and went onto the likes of the flop comedy Mixed Nuts (1994); the angel romantic comedy Michael (1996); Youve Got Mail (1998), a film about e-mail romance that felt like it was made by people who had never logged on in their lives; the John Travolta comedy Lucky Numbers (2000) about a lottery scam; and Julie and Julia (2009). I must admit to not being a particular fan of Nora Ephrons films. Its not anything to do with typical bloke aversion to the Chick Flick label that most of Ephrons films fall under its more that her films seemed made with a frothy bubbliness that emerges as too cute for its own good.
Bewitched suffers from the same problem. In remaking the series, Nora Ephron and her co-writing sister Delia have served the concept up in a way that seems postmodern to the point of being precious namely that Nicole Kidman is a witch who desires a normal life and marriage who then gets the role as Samantha in a remake of the original show. There are times that the play between the two is cleverly conducted like the audition scene where Nicole Kidmans reactions with Will Ferrell blurs between lines in the script and her natural response as a witch. Ultimately though, what we have is not Bewitched up on the big screen but a standard Nora Ephron light romantic comedy about a couple finding mutual romantic fulfilment despite their differences a la When Harry Met Sally ..., Sleepless in Seattle and Youve Got Mail that just happens to use the Bewitched series as a backdrop. You often get the impression that Nora Ephron keeps remaking the same basic plot over and over.
Ephron at least has an impressive cast. In terms of looking like the original characters, there are few actors better suited in terms to stepping into the roles of Samantha and Endora than Nicole Kidman and Shirley MacLaine. Yet for all the casting, this is one area where the film fails to ignite. Shirley MacLaine is an actress who can give the sort of arch show-stealing performance that Agnes Moorehead specialized in in her sleep. Despite this, Ephron fails to use Shirley MacLaine and gives us surprisingly few scenes where she gets to open up and do her stuff. However, the biggest stumbling block is the pairing of Nicole Kidman and Will Ferrell. Both are actors at almost opposite extremes Nicole Kidman is an exactingly studious method actor; while Will Ferrell, someone I have yet to warm to on screen, is a comic who emerged from success on Saturday Night Live (1975 ) into an A-list comedy career. Ferrell seems to suggest a mix of Ron Perlman and Jim Carrey and specializes in performances that make much of his big, lugubrious frame flailing about in hysterics. Indeed, it is of some irony that in the film here Will Ferrell plays an egocentric character who intentionally upstages Nicole Kidmans Samantha as in watching the film Ferrells performance similarly has a showboating Look at Me loudness that is constantly dragging the attention away to him from the more subdued Kidman. The two do not seem to connect romantically there is never any sense in the film that what they are engaged in has a chemistry that goes any further than the moment the shot ends.
Bewitched is a film that gets by on an occasional cuteness of one-liners and a bubbliness. Ultimately, there is the sense of another tv show having been made a mess of by people who have decided to write their own interpretations onto it and of Nora Ephron herself having failed to make a film that amounts to anything more than the sum of its self-congratulatory cuteness.