Perhaps more so than any other cinematic genre, it seems that animated films are charged with portraying good role models for children. A few years ago, someone noticed the fact that none of Pixars films had featured a female leading character and asked the reasonable question of when the studio was going to provide a female protagonist. Pixar duly picked up on this and Brave was the result. They also went to the extent of hiring a female director in Brenda Chapman, as well as putting two women on the script (Chapman and former Disney writer Irene Mecchi) and allowing the film to be produced by another woman (Katharine Sarafian) this despite the scarcity of women on the principal credits on their other films (the sole exception being Darla K. Anderson). Even then, Pixars attempt to portray an equal opportunities work environment did not work out as planned. Brenda Chapman quit part way through production citing creative differences and the film was placed in the hands of Mark Andrews. Try as they might, Pixar still seems a boys club despite the effort made to demonstrate sexual equality here, where more than anything Braves strong female presence seems something that has simply been arranged for the occasion. It is noted that Brenda Chapman was not an in-house Pixar director her only previous directorial outing has been as co-director on DreamWorks The Prince of Egypt (1998) (although she had contributed the story for Cars). Similarly, Irene Mecchi had only worked on the scripts for Disney films such as The Lion King (1994), The Hunchback of Notre Dame (1996) and Hercules (1997), and had not previously worked for Pixar. Katharine Sarafian was suddenly promoted to producer after previously being a general dogsbody on various Pixar films where her most senior position had been as an assistant producer on The Incredibles.
Brave kicks in with a welcome raucousness. It has a bawdy sense of knockabout humour that is a good deal rougher and more physical than most of Pixars other films. This certainly gives it a great deal of energy that carries over its rougher patches. Merida, who seems identified by a wild tangle of flaming red hair more than anything else, is a modern heroine in the mould that Disney introduced from The Little Mermaid (1989) and Beauty and the Beast (1991) onwards someone who is as capable as the men around her and stands up against social expectation rather than allows anybody to tell her what to do. Billy Connolly has equal fun as her father, giving the sort of rowdy performance that he was born to give. The animation is expectedly luscious with much placed into detailing the Scottish forests, lochs and hillsides. All of this appears to be heading towards the expected story arc of Merida standing up to defy social expectations and going away into the wilderness on a bildungsroman. Nothing outstandingly original but then Pixar have a habit of taking familiar stories and characters and making them work with an amazing freshness.
Only Brave proceeds to get weird. The plucky independent heroine story arc abruptly morphs into a variant on Disneys very similar Brother Bear (2003) wherein the magic spell causes Emma Thompsons mother to turn into a bear. The rest of the film consists of Meridas running around trying to bring her mother back to human form. The sheer wackiness of the premise does the film in it never particularly worked in Brother Bear either, even if both films try to make the best of what they have. You can have fun imagining how the pitch session for Brave went to the Disney executives imagine a cross between Braveheart (1995) and Brother Bear, Wait, but wasnt Brother Bear one of our least grossing box-office films of the 1990s/2000s, the junior boardroom executive might chip in. Shut up, hed be told, dont question, its Pixar. Theyre creative geniuses and everything they do is a box-office hit. There seems something going on at Pixar akin to the same creative lunacy that infected Disney around the early 2000s where they produced such creative scratch of the head concepts as Aztec emperor turns into a llama The Emperors New Groove (2000), Treasure Island (1883) in outer space Treasure Planet (2002), a film about talking cattle Home on the Range (2004) and one involving talking animals taking on alien invaders Chicken Little (2005), not to mention Brother Bear itself. Why the studio would want to recycle such a loopy premise a second time around is baffling.
Brave is competently made, likeable in a knockabout way, reaches a certain triumphal charge at its end but lacks the enormously endearing Pixar magic that you can point to in fairly much any of the films listed in the top paragraph. Certainly, it is hard to imagine that the film would inspire audiences to want to take Disney package tours to Scotland as are being advertising at the start of the film.