The director of Chocolat is Lasse Hallström who previously made the likes of Abba The Movie (1977) and just prior to this made the incredibly overrated The Cider House Rules (1999), a work that reduced John Irvings fine black comic bite and line-up of eccentrics to typical Hollywood sentimental mush, and later did little better with Annie Proulxs novel in The Shipping News (2001) or Casanova (2005), before finding his true calling with Nicholas Sparks adaptations such as Dear John (2010), Safe Haven (2013) and A Dogs Purpose (2017). That same banality infects Chocolat. Chocolat sets up clichéd Apollonian-Dionysian conflicts free-spiritiedness and joie de vivre vs order, tradition, religion and temperance. Although, having staked its conflict out, the film never gets particularly worked up about its outrages and the end lets the antagonists off the hook incredibly lightly. Hallstrom never finds anything to say that is not a cliché. For all Chocolats championing of joie de vivre over tranquilite, one suspects that Hallstrom was more on the side of tranquilite the film is so frustratingly mannered. The way it is pitched it suggests that Juliette Binoche is a catalyst in the unleashing of frustrated passions but when it comes to passions everything almost entirely takes places almost off screen the most we ever see is Juliette Binoche and Johnny Depp kissing in medium angle, for instance.
In fact, Lasse Hallström seems opposed to the Magical Realist elements and plays them down, making the magical transformations of personality seem wholly unremarkable. Compare Chocolat to either Like Water for Chocolate or Woman on Top these are films where the respective directors delight in and takes exuberant flights of fantasy along with the unleashed passions. At most, Chocolats big climactic transformation has Alfred Molina found drunk in the shop window after an orgy of chocolate eating.
Juliette Binoche is a lovely actress but she is all wrong for the part (apart from being the only actor in the principal cast who is actually French). Her persona is a shy and quiet. Unfortunately, the role here is one that needs someone who shines larger than life with either the sunniness that Penelope Cruz displayed in Woman on Top or the saintly radiance of Lumi Cavazos in Like Water for Chocolate.
For reasons inexplicable, Chocolat became a favourite with the Academy Awards crowd and it was nominated for that years Best Picture Award, Best Adapted Screenplay, Best Music, Juliette Binoche for Best Actress and Judi Dench for Best Supporting Actress, although won none of these.