Defendor comes as welcome anathema to most of these serious superhero films in that it seems determined to puncture the superheroic balloon they operate in. Here the central character is not a superhero but a slightly backward man who believes in the heroic black-and-white morality of a superhero and keeps trying to enforce this on a world that only laughs at the notion. Rather than a gleaming armoured Batmobile, Woody Harrelsons Defendor prowls the streets in a garbage truck; rather than a sleek costume with utility belt, he applies shoe polish around his eyes as a mask, is tripping over the wires of his devices, while his female companion is grumbling at the difficulty of finding obsolete VHS tapes for his portable recorder. His hi-tech devices consist of nothing more than a handful of marbles or a jar of wasps flung at evildoers and lemon juice squirted in peoples eyes something that more often has the effect of reducing his opponents to laughter. The disparity is perhaps no more aptly shown than when he keeps referring to Kat Dennings hooker as his Lois Lane, even as she is smoking a crack pipe and stealing his first edition comic-books to sell.
Defendor is not the first film to deal with the deluded individual who merely believes or pretends that they have superpowers. There have been previous variations on the theme such as Hero at Large (1980), Blankman (1994), Orgazmo (1997) and perhaps closest to this Special (2006), featuring Michael Rapaport who started to believe he was a superhero after undergoing pharmaceutical trials. Indeed, 2010, the year that Defendor goes into wide release, seems to be filled with variations on the idea, including the Australian Griff the Invisible (2010), the high-profile Kick-Ass (2010) and James Gunns Super (2010), even Superheroes (2011), a documentary about people fighting crime in superhero costumes in the real world, while just preceding all of these was the South Korean A Man Who Was Superman (2008) and even the Disney animated film Bolt (2008) about a talking dog that thinks it is a superhero.
While Hero at Large, Blankman et al have played the idea of the deluded non-superhero as a spoof of the superhero genre, director/writer Peter Stebbings has much grander ambitions than this. On one level, Defendor is a comedy about an inept individual playing out the role of a superhero. However, Stebbings has clear affection for Woody Harrelsons central character and plays the film for more than easy laughs. Woody Harrelson gives a sterling performance in the role. It is the same character that Woody played on Cheers (1982-93) but maybe a few digits down the IQ ladder and a whole lot more down the social developmental ladder. Harrelson, who is rapidly becoming one of the most underrated actors in the US, gives it his all. When the bad guys start ridiculing his dialogue Who writes your lines? Spiderman? who cannot fall for his adorable pout that is almost verging on breaking into tears I write my own lines or the images of him tripping over himself as he goes into surveill the bad guys. It is he that pins the character of Arthur as an affectingly lovable mix of pitiably deluded and comic gaucheness. Despite constantly deflating such, Peter Stebbings eventually pushes the role into a heroism sort of the same guileless dim-wittedness wins out by having an untarnished heart of gold that Forrest Gump (1994) embodied. The screenplay takes the odd misstep while we get a handful of flashbacks to Arthurs childhood, what we needed was an explanation of how Arthur became Defendor but Woody Harrelson remains the films soul.
Peter Stebbings manages to bring together a great cast. The show is dominated by Woody Harrelson but excellent also is rising and talented star Kat Dennings as the hooker with the grudging heart of gold who becomes Harrelsons companion. The relationship between the two of them is one of the strongest parts of the film. Elias Koteass role as a corrupt cop needed more development we are not sure why he seems to be leading criminal operations on the street. Nor does Sandra Oh get up to much, although there is a fine performance from Clark Johnson as the oddly sympathetic and understanding cop confidante.
Director/writer Peter Stebbings was previously best known as an actor and was a regular on the Canadian tv series Traders (1996-2000) and in the genre series Jeremiah (2002-4), as well as playing a leading role in K-19: The Widowmaker (2002). Stebbings had previously written the relationship drama Jack and Jill vs the World (2008) and Defendor was his debut as a director.
(Winner for Best Actor (Woody Harrelson) at this sites Best of 2009 Awards).