Doctor Strange had appeared on screen before in the not bad tv movie Dr. Strange (1978), which was one of a package of Marvel Comics titles brought up for television (something that also spawned the The Amazing Spiderman (1977-9) and The Incredible Hulk (1977-81) tv series). There Strange was played by Peter Hooten, but the film failed to attract sufficient interest to sell as a series. Dr Strange has appeared in episodes of other Marvel animated tv series and has often been suggested as a film property. Wes Craven was associated with a film adaptation throughout the 1990s and Guillermo Del Toro in the early 2000s. The only actual Dr Strange film during this period has been Doctor Strange (2007), one of a series of occasional animated spinoffs from the Marvel Cinematic Universe. However, there was also Full Moons Doctor Mordrid (1992), which did a fine, low-budgeted capturing of the essence of the comic-book in all but name.
Doctor Strange now emerges on screen as part of the Marvel Comics Universe. This had begun with the increasing success of films such as Blade (1998), X-Men (2000), Spider-Man (2002), Daredevil (2003), Hulk (2003), The Punisher (2004), Elektra (2005), Fantastic Four (2005), Man-Thing (2005), Ghost Rider (2007) and officially began with Iron Man (2008) and the successive likes of Thor (2011), The Avengers (2012), Guardians of the Galaxy (2014), Ant-Man (2015), Deadpool (2016), Black Panther (2018) and sequels to almost all of the above, as well as the tv series Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. (2013 ), Daredevil (2015 ), Agent Carter (2015-6), Jessica Jones (2015 ), Luke Cage (2016 ), The Defenders (2017 ), Iron Fist (2017 ) and Runaways (2017 ). Stranges appearance had been tipped in a throwaway line in Captain America: The Winter Soldier (2014) which does kind of create a continuity clash in that that film took place two years earlier where S.H.I.E.L.D. already had Strange under observation whereas here the date that everything begins is said to be 2016. One must compliment (?) Doctor Strange in that it is also a film that is not constantly finding the need to drop continuity Easter Eggs apart from a post-credits appearance from Chris Hemsworths Thor, there is nothing else that ties in to any of the other films as though perhaps the filmmakers were aware of how much the MCU had becomes an insider joke and determined to make this a standalone effort.
I had mixed feelings about the selection of Scott Derrickson as director. In comparison to Wes Craven and Guillermo Del Toro who both made you excited about the possibilities, Derrickson has been a frustrating hit and miss director. He first appeared with the okay Hellraiser: Inferno (2000) and then went onto the commercial success of The Exorcism of Emily Rose (2005) wherein Derricksons proclivities as an evangelical Christian became evident, wildly distorting the original true story and turning it into a faith over rationalism legal debate. I had more of a liking for Derricksons follow-up, the remake of The Day the Earth Stood Still (2008), than most did, while I found his next, the horror film Sinister (2012), which was well critically received, to be overrated. The subsequent Deliver Us From Evil (2014), a return to true-life possession and exorcism stories, was better than Emily Rose. Doctor Strange has at least gained Derrickson the best notices and biggest box-office of his career so far. Derrickson has also written Urban Legends: Final Cut (2000), and produced the Christian horror film The Visitation (2006), the horror film Kirsty (2014) and Sinister 2 (2015), as well as wrote/produced Devils Knot (2013) based on true story of the West Memphis Three.
The film does play free with some of the mythos of the comic-book. One of these is the issue that loomed over the film before it opened of whitewashing something that killed Gods of Egypt (2016) earlier in the year. The film seems stuck in an unenviable position of either whitewashing or having to go with racial stereotypes. In the comic-book, The Ancient One is a cliche figure of the all-powerful aging Eastern mystic who talks in inscrutable epigrams. However, his replacement by Tilda Swinton has less to do with avoiding racial cliches or rewriting to popular appeal than it does to do with kowtowing to the all-important Chinese box-office in that Kamar-Taj is said to reside in Tibet, which is of course a territory that China has occupied since 1950 and has vehemently resisted all efforts by its native people to assert their national sovereignty. For the film, Kamar-Taj has been displaced a few hundred miles over the border from Tibet into neighbouring Nepal. We get a few other changes Wong is upgraded from Dr Stranges manservant to a fellow novice, while Chiwetel Ejiofor plays another associate called Mordo who in the comic-books is meant to be a Transylvanian nobleman called Baron Mordo and crucially is a super-villain. Mordos origin arc was as a pupil to The Ancient One who goes rogue so clearly this is a storyline that is being set up for future sequels (something that is suggested by the second post-credits scene).
I have to commend Scott Derrickson. He does better with Doctor Strange than I expected he would. He plays around with some of the elements but mostly gets the look, feel and mythos right. There are all the trappings of the comic-book the Eye of Agamotto, the Cloak of Levitation (which almost becomes its own character and steals just about every scene it appears in), the Sanctum Sanctorum (which is designed right as though it came direct from the comic panel). Most of all though, the film excels in the visual depiction of the astral plane, especially during the journey that Tilda Swinton sends Benedict Cumberbatch on at the outset and subsequent sequences, which perfectly tap the psychedelic esoterica and mind-tripping visions that the comic-book used to specialise in.
I also liked Derricksons conception of the character. He has made an effort to get away from the cliche of the sorcerer tossing off coloured power blasts or chanting arcane phrases something that dogged the 2007 animated film. Instead we get a conception of magic in terms of harnessed forces and energy coigns, of insta-portals created in mid-air and doorways that lead to different landscapes. The visual effects are top quality, even if the dimensional folding owes a little too much to Inception (2010). Derrickson and the various effects companies create some enthralling sequences the aforementioned astral journey; the chase and fight through the Sanctum Sanctorum and into the mirror universe with Mads Mikkelsen folding the landscape around in every direction until it looks like the characters are fleeing/falling through a collage of M.C. Escher paintings; or the climactic sequence where Benedict Cumberbatch fights Mads Mikkelsen through a Hong Kong street scene where the mass destruction is being run in reverse and then creates a timeloop to trap Dormammu.
The one thing that anchors the film and without which it would not work is Benedict Cumberbatch who slips into the title role as though he were born to it. Cumberbatch has made a meteoric rise, ticking it seems all the boxes of fan favourite and womens pin-up to enormous success as both a popular and a seriously acclaimed actor, even being nominated at all of the major awards (Academy, Golden Globes, Emmys, BAFTAs) within only the space of the five years since he first appeared virtually out of nowhere in the tv series Sherlock (2010 ). As Doctor Strange, Cumberbatch has the difficult position of portraying an arrogant, self-important surgeon in the opening scenes and then having to switch about and become essentially an everyman who is struggling to abandon a Western rationalist way of thinking and absorb into Eastern mysticism, while also making the journey sympathetic and humorous to us. That he straddles such a range is all to Cumberbatchs credit. When the Cloak of Levitation settles on his shoulders and flaps up behind him with awesome cool, it is the superhero origin story morphing into the mature familiar character and feels something perfectly earned.
Benedict Cumberbatch subsequently returned as Doctor Strange in Thor: Ragnarok (2017).
(Nominee for Best Actor (Benedict Cumberbatch), Best Special Effects and Best Production Design at this sites Best of 2016 Awards).