While trying not to fall into the cynicism and accusations of selling-out that the fan press greets every successful low-budget director they feel they have discovered who then makes a big-budget film, one does feel disappointed in Heavenly Creatures. While good, it never succeeds in scaling the heights ascended by Bad Taste, Meet the Feebles or Braindead. Certainly, it does show a director who has matured in a remarkably short period of time within the space of three films, Peter Jackson went from a genuine seat-of-the-pants filmmaker to someone who can use the Panavision frame, helicopter shots and CGI effects with a fluidity that often cries out in its boldness. Some of the photography here like the cameras circling the Port Hills or the mid-shot jumps between the real world and fantasy is simply marvellous.
At the same time though, Peter Jackson is still the teenage kid with a Bolex making home movies and taking great delight in conjuring up novel trick effects. Heavenly Creatures jumps in with all manner of effects magic plasticine figures come to life, morphing landscapes, unicorns, giant butterflies and a malevolent Orson Welles stepped out of The Third Man (1949) and still in black-and-white. It is an impressive smorgasbord that Jackson serves up, yet at the same time one wonders, what is the point of all the Cinefex trickery? 1994 seemed a year where everybody was making lesbian-lovers-turned-killer movies with the Canadian Fun (1994) and the British Butterfly Kiss (1995) also coming out around this same time. Both Fun and Butterfly Kiss create disturbing psychological portraits of psychopathically misguided lesbian infatuation. The least likely thing, when you think about it, that a film about lesbianism and murder should be is a CGI effects vehicle. Contrarily, Peter Jackson stated that the reason that he made Heavenly Creatures was a desire to try out the CGI technology he had just purchased.
You can see what drew Peter Jackson to the true-life Parker-Hulme murder that happened in 1954 not the historical incident but the fact that he seems to want to leap off into the Fourth World with the two girls. In the documentary Good Taste Meets Bad Taste (1988), we are given a portrait of Peter Jacksons younger years where he made plasticine stop-motion animated short films, not unlike the girls here. Jacksons interest in the Parker-Hulme story seems less anything to do with portraying an incident that is well fixed within the New Zealand psyche than it is an affinity with the two girls florid dream lives. For all that, the dreamland conjured up by the film remains resolutely unfantastic. While some of the unicorns, butterflies and morphings achieve brief moments of fantastic wonder, the dreamland never means anything on a symbolic level. Before he developed the wings that made him into an A-list director, Peter Jackson seemed regrettably stuck at being a physical director. His earliest films work the best because they are live-action cartoons his idea of subtlety here is crudely cutting away to the heads of plasticine figures being chopped off when the girls get annoyed. Instead of showing the nature of the psychopathology that drove the two girls, all Jackson does is get inside their fantasies along with them but the great irony is that for all this he never tells us what is going on inside their heads. He is however aided considerably by good playing from Melanie Lynskey and particularly Kate Winslet in her big screen debut.
I may be alone in being a New Zealander who regards Heavenly Creatures as a so-so film most other New Zealanders regard it very highly and it topped a poll of the best New Zealand films. (In a side note, I also briefly lived two houses away from the girls school that appears at the opening of the film). The Parker-Hulme murder does seem to be one that is strangely fixated in the national psyche it had already fueled two books and a stage play prior to the film. After Heavenly Creatures came out, an intensive international search was made for the whereabouts of the real Pauline Parker and Juliet Hulme and in an irony that was surely greater than any fiction, it was discovered that Juliet Hulme is nowadays better known as novelist Anne Perry who specializes in writing Victorian murder mysteries, while Pauline Parker was later discovered living in Kent, England.
Peter Jackson next went onto the flop ghost comedy The Frighteners (1996). He followed this with the highly successful The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring (2001), The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers (2002) and The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (2003), which served to turn Jackson into an A-list Hollywood director. Subsequently, Jackson went on to his remake of King Kong (2005), the afterlife film The Lovely Bones (2009) and The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (2012), The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug (2013) and The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies (2014). Jackson has also produced District 9 (2009) and The Adventures of Tintin (2011).
(Nominee for Best Actress (Kate Winslet), Best Supporting Actress (Melanie Lynskey) and Best Cinematography at this sites Best of 1994 Awards).