Hercules Reborn came out the same time as the twin Hercules movies of 2014 The Legend of Hercules (2014) with Kellan Lutz and the high-profile Dwayne Johnson-starring Hercules (2014) from Brett Ratner. Hercules Reborn was released to dvd stores ten days before Hercules came out in theatres.
The Asylum have clearly cut a few corners when it comes to their version of Hercules. For one, all of the Greeks warriors wear Roman centurion uniforms where clearly someone has rented a bunch of costumes on the cheap and just hoped that nobody would notice the difference. Characters also have relentlessly modern attitudes and turns of speech although after Hercules: The Legendary Journeys (1994-9), it is unlikely anybody would care about that.
The other thing is that we have a Hercules that is stripped of fairly much anything to do with the original Greek myths. This Hercules does claim to be a demi-god but that could just be drunk boasting, while the only actual element from the original myths is his killing of his wife Megara and children, which the film blames on Nikos anyway. This de-mythicised Hercules is not any different from the Hercules of the various 1960s Italian peplum where he was no more than a heroic muscleman who would intervene to overthrow tyrants and help the downtrodden, while any larger battles with mythic creatures or mention of the gods of Olympus was eliminated. Even then, the original peplum could be counted on for at least one feat of superhuman strength per film but there is little of that here the arena where the rebellion takes place has Hercules at one point chained to two large boulders, leading you to expect a scene where he tears the chains out or swings the boulders around his head but that never happens. At most, this Hercules is a good fighter.
Wrestler John Hennigan makes for an okay Hercules, a little more animated than many of bodybuilders that have inhabited the role. One of the big pluses is Asylum regular Dylan Vox who does well as the villain of the show. On the other plus side, the location shooting in Morocco also makes the film look a whole lot better budgeted than it is. Director Nick Lyon throws in some surprisingly bloody fight scenes. The results make for a strictly average but certainly never less than watchable film. When you think about it that makes it a whole lot better than can be said of either Hercules and The Legend of Hercules, both of which ended up being laughed off the screen by audiences.
Director Nick Lyon has made a number of other low-budget genre films, including the likes of Grendel (2007), Species: The Awakening (2007), Annihilation Earth (2009), Zombie Apocalypse (2011), Rise of the Zombies (2012), Foreclosed (2013), Bermuda Tentacles (2014), Stormageddon (2015), They Found Hell (2015) and Isle of the Dead (2016).