Nearly forty years after the original came out, we get this remake. It comes as part of the ongoing firesale that has been happening since the 1990s when Disney properties have been relentlessly recycled. We have had remakes of other animated films with The Jungle Book (1994), 101 Dalmatians (1996), Maleficent (2014), Cinderella (2015), The Jungle Book (2016) and Beauty and the Beast (2017), plus Disney conducting remakes of live-action films such as That Darn Cat (1997), Flubber (1997), The Parent Trap (1998), Freaky Friday (2003), Herbie: Fully Loaded (2005), The Shaggy Dog (2006), Race to Witch Mountain (2009) and Tron Legacy (2010).
The idea of a remake of Pete's Dragon did little to enthuse me. It was not a film that seemed to be crying out for a remake. Its slapstick knockabout style filled with wildly overacting villains, not to mention the effects where a dragon could be represented by a big cartoon figure, seemed to belong to a whole other era. That is perhaps why David Lowery sees the need to so completely rewrite the original such that we now have two films that barely resemble one another. The two films even have wildly different tones the 1977 film was light-hearted knockabout slapstick filled with comic caricatures; the 2016 film is far more serious and realistically grounded and comes without any comedy element.
David Lowery, previously the director of St. Nick (2009) and Aint Them Body Saints (2013), has abandoned all but the basic shell of the 1977 film the idea of the boy with the invisible dragon as companion. The 1977 film involved Pete being adopted by drunken lighthouse keeper Mickey Rooney and his daughter Helen Reddy. The lighthouse has been eliminated we seem to be in some northwestern small town located inland (a well disguised location shoot in New Zealand) and the nearest equivalents are Robert Redford as an old timer with a penchant for storytelling (profession not mentioned) and Bryce Dallas Howard as his daughter who is a forest ranger. The 1977 film dwelt little on Petes origin. Most of that film was centred around the attempts of Pete to stay out of the hands of a villainous hillbilly family headed by a wildly OTT Shelley Winters who believed she owned Pete, and a shady medicine show man (Jim Dale), as well as the slapstick chaos that Pete and the invisible Elliott caused around the town. There are no equivalents of Shelley Winters and Jim Dale here; the nemesis is Karl Urban who is characterised as a logger who is obsessed with capturing Elliott. The slapstick scenes running around the town are replaced by a single big climactic chase rescuing Elliott.
The other major change is that we get an origin story for Pete, which makes the film now more into a wild child tale along the lines of Tarzan or Mowgli. Elliott is cast in terms of an endangered animal and so we get a very familiar story arc that we have seen in films from E.T. The Extra-Terrestrial (1982) through Harry and the Hendersons (1987) to Loch Ness (1996) and Mighty Joe Young (1998) where those who have befriended Elliott struggle to save him from those who want to capture and exploit him. Elliott goes from a cartoon character to a CGI dragon. This ends up being a major misstep not that I think a cartoon dragon would have worked today either but the upshot is that we get a realist film that jarringly features a cute, cuddly dragon that for all the world looks like a big green version of the Luckdragon from The Neverending Story (1984).
Pete's Dragon is one of those films that you can call nice and then forget about five minutes later. David Lowery hits all the right buttons, sweeps emotion and feeling where he needs to engages us in wanting Elliott to escape, gives us shots of the dragon in flight that occasionally make you go wow. But it is also a film that hits each of its beats so predictably that there is nothing of any surprise or sincerity beyond the formula.