What Peter Greenaway does is use Shakespeare more as a text to bounce his accustomed eccentricities almost ritualistic runs of numerical sequences and recitations of arcane lists throughout off. The resulting effort emerges more of a gay pride parade than anything resembling classic Shakespeare. The screen is packed with nude dancing nymphs of both sexes; Caliban is nude, bald and painted in mottled pink and purple body paint and is sent to twist his way through the sets like a centipede with back pains; the costume designers have planted their tongues in cheek and gone absolutely wild the visiting Milanese, for instance, are dressed in three foot diameter Francis Drake collars, even wider brimmed feathered hats and platform soles to hysterically funny effect; paper is blown through the sets right throughout the film; random, often endlessly repeated images are inserted in the middle of the screen in boxed inserts and overlays.
The film opens on an amazingly silly scene with swimming mermaids and John Gielgud attempting to conjure up the tempest while bathing in a swimming pool with a toy ship at the same time as a nude boy nymph urinates into the water. Greenaway treats John Gielgud as though he were a clockwork Shakespeare-spouting automaton to be wound-up and sent moving obliviously through the caterwauling mardi gras as just another absurdity in the spectacle. To add confusion to even those familiar with the play, John Gielgud voices all the character in the film while Ariel is played by several different actors, the effect of which is naturally thoroughly bewildering.
All of which might have been interesting as a three-and-a-half minute music video but when dragged out to two-and-a-quarter hours almost collapses under the unintentional hilarity of the exercise. This is the usually entertaining Peter Greenaway probably at his most pretentious. The actual images and recitations from the titular books do look more interesting than anything else, created as they are with some amazing computer animation and optical effects.
Peter Greenaways other films of genre interest are: the surreal post-holocaust documentary The Falls (1980); The Cook, the Thief, His Wife & Her Lover (1989); several episodes of the modernised tv series A TV Dante (1989-91); the miraculous child film The Baby of Macon (1993); and The Tulse Luper Suitcases: The Moab Story (2003), The Tulse Luper Suitcases Part 2: From Vaux to the Sea (2004) and The Tulse Luper Suitcases Part 3: From Sark to the Finish (2003), a surreal mock biography that is part of a mammoth multimedia work from Greenaway.
Other adaptations of the The Tempest include: the famous Forbidden Planet (1956), which relocated the story in science-fictional terms; Derek Jarmans fine The Tempest (1979); Paul Mazurskys modernised Tempest (1982); The Tempest (1998), a tv version that locates the story during the American Civil War; and Julie Taymors visually fantastical The Tempest (2010) with a female Prospero.
Clip from the film here:-