WHEN MARNIE WAS THERE
(Omoide no Mani)
A ghost story or any type of traditional Japanese kaidan eiga is not something you associate with Studio Ghibli. Though they feature creatures and monstrous figures, almost invariably these are revealed to have a vulnerable side to them when greeted with pure-hearted innocence. Indeed, what When Marnie Was There resembles more is the type of bildungsroman that Hayao Miyazaki essentially invented with My Neighbor Totoro (1988) wherein a young girl or child goes away to the country and finds a magical secret world that opens up for them there. We have seen variations on this in other anime such as The Cat Returns (2002), Oblivion Island: Haruka and the Magic Mirror (2009), Summer Wars (2009), Children Who Chase Lost Voices from the Deep (2011), A Letter to Momo (2011) and Wolf Children (2012), even Arrietty. There is little here that approaches anything we would associate with a traditional Western (or even Japanese ghost story). There is nothing that ever sets out to scare us instead, what we have is more a story about the life of a lonely girl and the growth of friendship.
Arrietty showed Hiromasa Yonebayashi as a perfectly capable inheritor of Hayao Miyazakis style. Similarly, When Marnie Was There is a very Miyazaki-esque film. Yonebayashi draws in the same ligne claire styled characteristic of Miyazaki clear outlined figures, bold use of colours and landscape and features the same focus on the tenderness of youth, the same genteel reverence for nature and elders. Screen When Marnie Was There without credits alongside any other of Miyazakis films for someone not familiar with them and I think they would be hard-pressed not to mistake it as one of his films. The major difference for those who know the difference is that When Marnie Was There is a much quieter film than most of Miyazakis work and never quite hits its emotional peaks as joyously.
The scenes of the friendship between Anna and Marnie comes with a lovely tenderness. I must confess that I never fully followed some of the plot strands that come in towards the end I was never sure why Marnie was confined to the upper room and how she managed to get free. There also seems much built up about how the silo is a scary place and may house ghosts but when we get there this dissipates into not being the case. The film at some points also confusingly vies between whether Marnie is a ghost or is simply a figure in Annas imagination. That said, the film does eventually bring all of these strands together in an ending that is sweet and tearfully sad.