Darkness comes backed by Brian Yuzna, a genre director of films such as Society (1989), Bride of Re-Animator (1990), Return of the Living Dead III (1993), The Dentist (1996) and Faust: Love of the Damned (2000), who has also produced a number of films for Stuart Gordon, most famously Re-Animator (1985). More recently, Brian Yuzna has set up a production house in Spain, Fantastic Factory, and produced a number of films for English-language release (as is the case with Darkness). Jaume Balaguero and Brian Yuzna manage to corral an impressive cast, including Anna Paquin; the greatly underrated Scottish actor Iain Glen, probably best known to international audiences as the villain in Lara Croft, Tomb Raider (2001); and the Swedish actress Lena Olin from acclaimed arthouse releases like The Unbearable Lightness of Being (1987) and Enemies: A Love Story (1989).
Darkness was originally released back in 2002. Though the film was shot for English-language audiences, it was not until 2004/5 that it received an international release. The problem was that US distributor Dimension Films dithered around and then decided to recut the film for a PG-13 rating. It has now been excised of some bad language, a scene where Iain Glen severs his finger and several scenes where the brother is attacked by the ghosts. One can only have contempt for a horror film that tries to recut itself to sell itself to a pre-teenage audience see also Soul Survivors (2001). There is the staggering sense of wondering what the point of doing so is if one wanted to watch R-rated films that had been cut so they could be viewed by general audiences they would have stayed home and watched public access tv. Indeed, what one can see on tv on contemporary shows such as The X Files (1993-2002) and CSI: Crime Scene Investigators (2000-15) is far more extreme than anything there is here. While cutting the film for conservative American audiences is one thing, it is insulting when this version, rather than the original, also gets foisted off into release in other countries, which have a far more liberal set of censorship standards than the USA.
On the other hand, the derision being poured in the direction of Darknesss PG-13 horrors can not be seen as the sole reason for its failure to work the truth is simply that it is not a very good film anyway. Jaume Balagueros The Nameless was a film primed with a good deal sinister mood that Balaguero failed to let pay off. There is a similar problem here. Balaguero creates some creepy images shadowy figures gathering around the boy and waiting in darkened rooms, something briefly seen scuttling across the ceiling but never builds them to anything that pays off with a big jolt. Elsewhere, the attempts to make us jump by falsely hyping the soundtrack with loud noises as figures pass in the foreground seem annoyingly contrived. Despite assembling a fine cast Anna Paquin, Iain Glen, Lena Olin the film throws all of them into roles of paper-thin substance that require nothing from any of them other than turning up and delivering lines.
Ultimately, what is most annoying about Darkness is its lack of substance as a screenplay. There is the sense that it has been thrown together as a collusion of horror clichés without much raison dêtre there are ghosts in the shadows, the House With a Sinister Past, the conspiring occult cabal, the father descending into madness possibly as a result of the malign influence of the house a la The Amityville Horror (1979). However, there is not much sense to any of it. The ghosts in the house are never explained indeed, the entire first half of the film is misleading in its efforts to convince us that we are watching is a haunted house film. For that matter, the fathers madness also proves to be misleading red herring that has nothing to do with what happens later. When what is going on is finally revealed, the behaviour that the occult set-up requires of the individuals in question is contrived to the point of incredulity. The blur of reality and illusion that comes at the climax is confusing. The film goes out on a downer of a twist ending that leaves audiences departing feeling annoyed the audience I saw the film with were vocal in their dissatisfaction.