Eden Lake was one version that emerged from England to quite a reasonable degree of acclaim. It was a directorial debut for James Watkins who had previously written the scripts for a number of other horror films My Little Eye (2002), Gone (2006) and The Descent Part 2 (2009). On the basis of Eden Lake, Watkins was subsequently hired to make the ghost story The Woman in Black (2012) for the revived Hammer Films. The other fascinating face that Eden Lake features is Michael Fassbender as the leading male (although not the principal character of the film) before he went onto international A-list status and prominent roles in Inglourious Basterds (2009), A Dangerous Method (2011), Prometheus (2012), The Counselor (2013) and as the young Magneto in the X-Men films, among others.
One of the complaints you could make about the aforementioned European Backwoods Brutality films is that they come from countries where the idea of a hostile divide between city slickers and backwoods hillbillies is not a sharp a one as it is in a country of such large expanse as the United States. Eden Lake strains to make the case for England. As soon as Kelly Reilly and Michael Fassbender have left the confines of the city, they are surrounded by uncouth provincial characters everywhere they turn children racing across their path on bicycles as they go to turn at the lights, another car rudely forcing its way into a parking spot ahead of them, the barman in the country pub ignoring Michael Fassbender, the mother who slaps her child in public, the sounds of raucous partying coming in through the window of their hotel room. When we arrive at the lake (which is in actuality located only a few minutes from Pinewood Studio, which in itself is thirty minutes from London, hardly the forgotten backwater of the UK the film paints it as), there is, not unlike the excellent Australian Natures Revenge film Long Weekend (1978), the constant imagery of the despoliation of nature by the uncaring locals Kelly Reilly and Michael Fassbenders idyll in the sun interrupted by a blaring ghetto blaster, the dog shitting in the sand or barking unleashed in Kelly Reillys face, the kids smashing the glass jars of the boy (James Gandhi) who collects bugs, and the surly taunts they give Michael Fassbender when he goes to ask them to turn the noise down.
Once he gets to the heart of the film, James Watkins gets his teeth into the audience and rarely lets up on the tension until right at the end. The characters are tight, well-played and certainly given much more roundedness than they are in the usual Backwoods Brutality film. Watkins gets a particularly gruelling tension out of the scene where ringleader Jack OConnell browbeats all of the other kids into taking turns stabbing a bound Michael Fassbender. There is the grim nastiness of the scene where Jack OConnell threatens to set James Gandhi alight if Kelly Reilly does not return a scene where we see her conflicted about surrendering or keeping on running for her life. Watkins chooses not to depict the end of the scene except from a single shots distance where you suspect if he did it would have pushed Eden Lake to a grim extreme. For all its reworking of the Backwoods Brutality cycle, this is a film that is centred in well-drawn tension, not in Torture Porn.
The film reaches an unsettling end [PLOT SPOILERS]. Here Kelly Reilly makes it to the village only to discover that the people who take her in are the parents of ringleader Jack OConnell. Then comes the disturbing moment where she realises that the brutal assault that she has undergone is suddenly being spun to show her as a murderer of one of the children. The end of the film and her eventual fate has nothing good to say about rural English life.