However, I, Madman has a considerable ingenuity that lifts it well above the run of the mill A Nightmare on Elm Street copy. The character of Dr Kessler is substantially more intriguing than the usual movie psycho. Tibor Takacs includes some wonderfully grisly scenes where Randall William Cook injects himself with novocaine and slices off his own facial features off with a scalpel to send as love gifts to the heroine and then cuts up the people in her life and reattaches their facial parts to himself. There is a tragic Phantom of the Opera-like to the villains love, although this does not get as much airing as it should. One would have preferred if Kessler were allowed to speak what eloquence such a character would have.
The most intriguing aspect of I, Madman is its double-structure, flipping between the plot of the book and the reading heroines life with both heroines being played by the same actress Jenny Wright. The film is filled with all manner of fascinating small details the way a rose knocked over in the book is mirrored in the real world; how when a tea kettle is placed on in the book, one starts whistling in the real world even though we never saw Jenny Wright put one on when she entered the apartment. Although Kessler is given a nominally rational explanation, by the end of the story we are never certain whether it was Brand or Kessler that has been pursuing the heroine certainly, the explanation that would rely on it being Brand offers no explanation of how the abovementioned incidents of meta-fictional synchronicity occurred.
Less effective is Tibor Takacss cast. Jenny Wright seems distant and not emotionally involved. Clayton Rohner lacks any conviction at all, looking hardly old enough to be out of college let alone a seasoned detective. The climax of the film is let down by Randall Cooks unconvincing stop motion animation. Takacs shoots in Canada like many other Canadian films, he attempts to give the impression the film is American-made and in one wonderful gaffe we have a downtown bus that is simply labelled Los Angeles.
Director Tibor Takacs has also made a number of other genre films including the very obscure Metal Messiah (1978) about a futuristic rock star; The Gate (1987) and its even better sequel Gate II (1990) about children unlocking a demonic gateway; Redline/Deathline (1997) set in a near-future Russia; the bizarre Nostradamus (2000) about a time-travelling occult war and the attempt to reincarnate the title character; Rats (2003) about an asylum of intelligent rats; Mansquito (2005) about mutant insect people; The Black Hole (2006) about an amok black hole and monster; and the monster movies Kraken: Tentacles of the Deep (2006), Ice Spiders (2007), Mega Snake (2007) and Spiders (2013); and the disaster movie NYC: Tornado Terror (2008) and Meteor Storm (2010).