Unfortunately, while Underworld sat just on the edge between all posture with no substance and the potentially interesting, Underworld: Evolution amplifies all the faults of Underworld and expands on none of the places that it did work. There is even less substance here than there was in Underworld. Essentially all that has happened is that the bigger budget has allowed Len Wiseman to go from a medium-budgeted series of kinetic fight sequences to a big showcase of CGI effects and action sequences. He throws these at us variously: a sequence with Kate Beckinsale driving a truck while a winged demon figure flies around the outside attacking her and Scott Speedman; lots of gore and makeup effects (there being an especially impressive demon figure who goes around impaling people with its wingtips); lots of fight sequences between vampires and werewolves (although these lack the revved up kick that they had in the first film); and numerous explosions, even a big climactic set-piece with a helicopter crashing down through the lair during the middle of combat and somehow becoming impaled on a rope bridge without causing it to collapse. Certainly, Underworld: Evolution is not as mindlessly empty-headed a vehicle of CGI bombast as Kate Beckinsales previous genre outing Van Helsing (2004). However, the action sequences are surprisingly unmemorable and ultimately Underworld: Evolution is no more than a slickly packaged adrenalin rush that is fine while it lasts but can hardly be remembered the moment the film is over.
Underworld: Evolution is especially poor in terms of story and character. It is a film where Len Wiseman invests a great deal of dramatic urgency and effort in the telling, only for one to come out of it not understanding much of what has happened. Certainly, anyone coming to see Underworld: Evolution without having seen Underworld would be highly confused as to what is going on who is who, the various sides and the connections between characters which are still confusing even when one has seen the first film. I had to sit down and think to work out whether Stephen Mackintoshs character was meant to be vampire or Lycan, for instance. Though the end of the film tells us that what has happened throughout has blurred the lines of how vampires and Lycans regard one another, we have no idea why. The plot circles around elements that in any other circumstances would be corny devices talismans that are a key to a secret location, clues to be found in long-forgotten memories, revelations about parentage, characters becoming more powerful and developing superpowers for little explained or contrived reasons.
The characters seem of so little importance to the film that the actors filling the parts are negligible Scott Speedman makes almost zero impression on the film and Kate Beckinsale barely more than he does. She has even been stripped of all the Gothic poses that Len Wiseman (now her real-life husband) put her through in the first film and is only there in a handful of lines of dialogue and a few action sequences. The character that does come to the fore is that of Marcus whose obsession with his brother and especially the sequence where he remonstrates Derek Jacobi about becoming a god have a great mad intensity to them. Derek Jacobi does present some class to the proceedings, although you wonder what a classic actor like Jacobi who is pointedly listed as being Sir Derek Jacobi on the end credits is doing in a mindless action vehicle like this.
This was followed by the prequel Underworld: Rise of the Lycans (2009) and a further sequel Underworld: Awakening (2012). Len Wiseman subsequently went onto helm Live Free or Die Hard/Die Hard 4.0 (2007) and the remake of Total Recall (2012), as well as to create/produce the tv series Sleepy Hollow (2013 ) and Lucifer (2015 ).
(Nominee for Best Makeup Effects at this sites Best of 2006 Awards).