Nevertheless, one cannot fault director Kevin Brownlows impeccable grasp of the subject matter. He screens footage from some fascinatingly obscure lost films the King Baggott Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde (1913), The Cat Creeps (1930) and Paul Lenis The Last Warning (1929). Profiles are offered of the major personalities of the era Boris Karloff, Bela Lugosi, Lon Chaney, Carl Laemmle, James Whale, Tod Browning, makeup artist Jack Pierce and some of the lesser-known players like directors Edgar G. Ulmer and Paul Leni. Brownlow delights in fannish trivia arguing in a point-for-point comparison of the superiority of the Spanish language Dracula (1931) over the Lugosi version; the tracing of the influences of The Golem (1920) and even F.W. Murnaus Sunrise: A Song of Two Humans (1927) on the Karloff Frankenstein. Brownlow manages to draw out some fascinatingly obscure facts that in The Phantom of the Opera the designs of the Paris Opera House were directly based on the recall of one designer who had intimate knowledge of the real Opera House; or how the Spanish language Dracula came about because Lupita Tovar was dating Universal production head Paul Kohner and he desired to create a vehicle for her.
David J. Skal, author of Dark Carnival: The Secret World of Tod Browning (1982) and Hollywood Gothic: The Tangled Web of Dracula from Novel to Screen (1990), is present (and listed as Historical Consultant on the credits). He offers up some interesting theories (although not ones that I am sure if I entirely agree with) that the popularity of Lon Chaneys grotesqueries during the silent era was an audience reaction to World War I where many servicemen returned from the trenches disfigured. This argument is debatable it does not explain the popularity of Lon Chaneys films in America, which was relatively unscathed by the horrors of World War I, as opposed to Britain and Europe. The argument also gets stretched when Skal tries to make analogy between mad scientist cinema and Dr Josef Mengele and the Nazi death camps, which were not established until 1940 when the period of Universal horror that the documentary covers was almost over. The argument is also strained where Skal draws the analogy to the horrors of World War I out by calling Abel Gances JAccuse (1937) a literalisation of Universals obsession with the grotesque while that is certainly what the film was about, Gance was in France half a world away from Universal and not making genre horror but a work in the surrealist tradition.
The documentary ends with The Wolf Man (1941). Lon Chaney Jrs Wolf Man was the last of the classic Famous Monsters to emerge and this is largely seen as the end of the Golden Age of Horror by many fans. One feels that Kevin Brownlow ended the documentary more with his real desire of focus the Golden Age of Horror rather than the titles stated target the Universal Studios horror story. What is not given mention is how Universal continued to make horror films throughout the 1940s. There were a good many Mummy and Invisible Man sequels, not to mention the famous monster team-ups beginning with Frankenstein Meets the Wolf Man (1943) and culminating in Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein (1948), as well as original works like Weird Woman (1944) and the Jungle Woman series. Certainly, none of these were classics and all were made on much cheaper budgets than their predecessors but Brownlow leaves them unmentioned. The documentary does touch upon some of the reasons for these the Laemmles going bankrupt in the mid-1930s and the studio being taken over by creditors who had no understanding of the horror cycle until they needed money and decided to start making monster sequels. One would have liked to have seen Kevin Brownlow extend the documentary throughout the war years as this period, even though it represents the studios decline as a producer of horror, is an equally important part of the story.
One regret about the film, while it is impeccably researched, is how few of the original players are left around for it to interview. In making the documentary some sixty years after the Golden Age passed, there are not that many of the talents that were present at the time still left alive. Brownlow manages to find a handful of actors and actresses who had minor parts in some of the Universal horrors Turhan Bey, Gloria Jean, Gloria Stuart, Lupita Tovar and merely a couple of people who had major roles Fay Wray and The Wolf Man screenwriter Curt Siodmak. All the rest certainly all those profiled are sadly now dead. The rest of the time Kevin Brownlow is left interviewing children of the principal players Carla Laemmle, Sara Karloff, Arianne Ulmer or people that offer their childhood recall of the films such as Famous Monsters of Filmland (1958-82) editor Forrest J. Ackerman, genre writer Ray Bradbury and actor James Karen, who are now septuagenarians and, in Ackermans case, octogenarian.
Kevin Brownlow is most famous as the co-director of the standout alternate world Nazis invade England film It Happened Here (1965). These days he makes documentaries about the classic era of Hollywood. These have included the likes of Hollywood: A Celebration of the American Silent Film (1980), Buster Keaton: A Hard Act to Follow (1983), D.W. Griffith: Father of Film (1993), Cinema Europe: The Other Hollywood (1996), Lon Chaney: A Thousand Faces (2000), The Tramp and the Dictator (2002), Cecil B. De Mille: American Epic (2004), So Funny It Hurt: Buster Keaton and MGM (2004), Garbo (2005) and Im King Kong: The Exploits of Merian C. Cooper (2005).
(Review copy provided by Kathy Tipping)