Certainly, 1974 was the year that Mel Brooks was at his height and Young Frankenstein is debatably his best work. Young Frankenstein is a homage to the Universal Frankenstein films. Perhaps Young Frankenstein works the best of all Mel Brookss films because Brooks has a clear affection for the originals and has made a major effort to recapture the look and style of the old Frankenstein films, reconstructing them in loving detail down to the Gothic sets and black-and-white lighting. Brooks even employed Kenneth Strickfaden who in fact uses some of the lab equipment that he created for the original films.
The plot is essentially a rerun of the third Universal film Son of Frankenstein (1939) wherein Basil Rathbones heir returns to reclaim his fathers heritage. Brooks sends up scenes from the originals Kenneth Mars does a witty parody of Lionel Atwills wooden-armed police inspector from Son of Frankenstein; an uncredited Gene Hackman mercilessly skewers O.P. Heggies blind hermit from Bride of Frankenstein (1935) this time setting the monsters finger on fire when he goes to light a cigar; and there is an amusing take on the scene where the monster encounters the little girl by the river bank in Frankenstein (1931).
Young Frankenstein was a huge success. Its humour struck a chord and was appreciated by a generation who had never seen the Universal originals. Although a more in-depth second viewing shows that outside of the parodies and scene recreations, Mel Brookss crasser jokes tend to rise to the fore Gene Wilder comments What big knockers upon regarding the castle door, Teri Garr replies Why, thank you, doctor. Some jokes horses whinnying every time Frau Bluchers name is mentioned tend to get overused to the point they are battered into submission. There is a certain vulgarity, nevertheless it is a film filled with inspired moments the monster and creator get to stage a tuxedo-and-tophat version of Puttin on the Ritz and in the end the monster sits up in bed with Elizabeth, reading the Wall Street Journal.
Brooks has also assembled one of the best casts he has ever worked with. All shine at their comic glory. Gene Wilder is an intensely annoying actor he tends to deliver everything at a wildly histrionic pitch shouted from the top of his lungs. This is probably one of the better roles that Wilder was ever given and he is at his best when delivering a parody of pained sincerity. There are other fine comic performances from the likes of Marty Feldman, Madeline Kahn and Teri Garr. Best of all is Peter Boyle as the monster. Boyle creates an amazing range of expressions with his eyes alone it is rather amusing to have a sympathetic monster who represents the only sane reaction amid the madcap goings-on about him. It is a shame that Peter Boyle never ever managed to find a role that he shone in again as he does here.
Young Frankenstein was a huge success and gave way to a host of other light-hearted Frankenstein spoofs, including Frankensteins Great Aunt Tillie (1985), Transylvania 6-5000 (1985), Frankenstein General Hospital (1988) and Frankenstein: The College Years (1991). There were then a series of films that tried to find a similar light-hearted tone for the vampire film, including the likes of Tender Dracula (1974), Vampira/Old Dracula (1975), Dracula, Father and Son (1976), Love at First Bite (1979) and Mama Dracula (1980), while Brooks himself returned to do the job with less-than-impressive results in Dracula: Dead and Loving It (1995).
Following the great success that was enjoyed by the Broadway adaptation of Mel Brooks The Producers (2001), Young Frankenstein was revived as a Broadway musical in 2007, although only met with mixed success.