AVPR: ALIENS VS PREDATOR REQUIEM
AVPR: Aliens vs Predator Requiem comes from Greg and Colin Strause who bill themselves as The Brothers Strause on screen. The Brothers Strause are better known as visual effects supervisors, starting out working for Light Matters/Pixel Envy in the mid-1990s and then forming their own company Hy*drau*lx. They are credited as visual effects supervisors on high profile films such as The Day After Tomorrow (2004), Aeon Flux (2005), Fantastic Four (2005), Poseidon (2006), 300 (2007) and Avatar (2009). The Brothers Strause began directing with various music videos and commercials, as well as a couple of short films, and AVPR: Aliens vs Predator Requiem was their debut as feature-film directors.
One supposed they should have had a sinking feeling about Aliens vs Predator Requiem after realising that the scriptwriter was Shane Salerno, who previously co-wrote the likes of Armageddon (1998) and Shaft (2000), as well as worked as a script doctor on Alien vs. Predator. Needless to say, The Brothers Strause are no equivalent of The Wachowski Brothers, or even for that matter the Farrelly Brothers, and Aliens vs Predator Requiem is disappointingly ill-conceived on almost all level. Alien and Aliens are classics of the genre because their respective directors Ridley Scott and James Cameron plunged their audiences into an intensively suspenseful and gruelling ride. Alien3 did so to a lesser extent, while Predator enjoyably mixed Alien up with action movie formula. More than that though, part of the reason that Alien became a classic was that it dug down into primal fears with the monster being deliberately associated with sexual imagery.
By the time of Aliens vs Predator Requiem, both the alien and the Predator have become no more than generic monsters. There is no build-up to the film, no unveiling of the various creatures threat. For that matter, there seems to be no point throughout where any of the characters even work out what they are dealing with what is going on is only meant to be assumed or inferred by referring to the other films. Even then the attacks, which all seem to be shot either at night or in the rain, are directed in a way that is often hard to see what is going on or even which species of alien is attacking some of the time. The Brothers Strause seem to have no concept of creating suspense rather the various aliens keep being thrown at an audience like pop-up shocks. These shocks get exceedingly lame like the father who says See, no monster to his kid before an alien occludes his reflection in the window and then smashes through to grab him.
Indeed, with the setting now being contemporary, Aliens vs Predator Requiem looks like no more than an attempt to export the Alien and Predator franchises as yet another 00s teen horror film a la the likes of They (2002), Darkness Falls (2003), The Fog (2005) et al. It is sad to compare the tedious scenes here with teen guys making derisive insults at one another or fighting over a girl in a swimming pool with the sheer mastery of suspense that Ridley Scott and James Cameron showed in their respective efforts. The scenes where the party try to make their way through the alien-infested town streets have nothing on the marines venture into the alien labyrinth in Aliens. The new spins on the creatures that we see often seem more absurd than anything else like the scene where we see the alien inserting eggs down the oesophagus of a pregnant woman as though it were an automatic tennis ball firing machine, or what looks like an Alien-Predator crossbreed that turns up at the climax and is a standard alien but now with dreadlocks.
The Strause Brothers subsequently went onto direct the alien invasion film Skyline (2010), as well as to produce Take Shelter (2011) about a man who has visions of the end of the world and the ecological catastrophe film The Bay (2012).