The movie version of Doom was in the pipeline for more than ten years. Critics greeted the version that finally emerged here with the usual range of negative reviews another flop of a videogame adaptation. This last is something that one disagrees with not the view that Doom is a flop but that all videogame adaptations have been flops. Certainly, a great many adaptations have been Super Mario Bros. (1993), Double Dragon (1994), Street Fighter (1994), Mortal Kombat: Annihilation (1997), Wing Commander (1999), Lara Croft, Tomb Raider (2001), Resident Evil (2002), House of the Dead (2003), Lara Croft, Tomb Raider: The Cradle of Life (2003), Alone in the Dark (2005), BloodRayne (2005), DOA: Dead of Alive (2006), Hitman (2007), In the Name of the King: A Dungeon Siege Tale (2007), Postal (2007), Far Cry (2008), Max Payne (2008), Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time (2010), Tekken (2010), Angry Birds (2016), Assassins Creed (2016) and Warcraft (2016) but there have also been some that have not Mortal Kombat (1995) had an enjoyable kinesis, Silent Hill (2006) an admirable degree of atmosphere, while Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within (2001) was excellent.
Doom is directed by former cinematographer Andrzej Bartkowiak, who had previously directed several slick but intellectually content free action films with the likes of Romeo Must Die (2000), Exit Wounds (2001) and Cradle 2 the Grave (2003) and a subsequent videogame adaptation with Street Fighter: The Legend of Chun-Li (2009). The script was tuned by Wesley Strick, who has a number of A-list screenplays to his credit including Arachnophobia (1990), Cape Fear (1991), Final Analysis (1992), Wolf (1994), The Saint (1997), The Glass House (2001), the remake of A Nightmare on Elm Street (2010) and Loft (2013), and has also directed the psycho-thriller The Tie That Binds (1995).
Doom is at least what one can say that you expect of a videogame adaptation a good deal of action and not a huge amount in the way of plot. That said, most fans of the original Doom games this author included emerged disappointed. The game consists of no more than an anonymous character running around a labyrinth shooting up various monsters. However, the film seems to fumble this essential concept it is some 40 minutes in before we even see a monster, for instance. Necessarily, the film has to expend some backstory explaining the set-up but in doing so the entertainingly kinetic violence of the game has been watered down. To his credit, Andrzej Bartkowiak creates some passable suspense during the wandering through the corridors with things jumping out but ultimately does nothing with any of it.
The monsters encountered are particularly unmemorable. One missed many of the games regular nemeses and features particularly the giant flying red fireball-breathing demons. Although, unlike the pathetically wimpy Resident Evil, Doom is not stinting when it comes to the considerable level of gore that was present in the original game and was released with an R rating. The film goes some way towards catering to gamer interest by introducing favourites like the BFG (Big Fucking Gun, initially nicknamed the Bio-Force Gun until the more colloquial sobriquet is applied by The Rock). And there is a 10 minute sequence near the end where the camera takes on the famous First Person Shooter point-of-view and races along taking on various monsters as a pair of hands in the centre of the frame wield a chaingun and even a chainsaw. For reasons unknown, the film chooses not to use the games explanation that the Martian base sits atop a gateway to Hell and that the creatures encountered are demons and instead substitutes an explanation about genetic experiments and mutated humans if anything, the film resembles the first Resident Evil movie far more than it does the Doom game. Many gamers saw this as a watering down of the games concept, possibly in an effort not to upset Christian morality groups.
The plot is essentially a reworking of Aliens (1986) a group of tough marines armed with big guns are sent in to investigate a facility and are massacred by monsters lurking in the darkened corridors, the two-faced company is found to be up to sinister experiments and so on. There are probably other sources that one could cite as well like Forbidden Planet (1956) and the idea of archaeologists having discovered the remnants of an ancient civilization and attempting to replicate the dead civilizations efforts to expand their mental/physical capacity, only to find that this is what ended up wiping them out and is now something that threatens the humans. Maybe you could also see a passing nod or two of John Carpenters Ghosts of Mars (2001) with its troupe of commandos fighting off human dead that have become possessed by resurrected Martian spirits.
The characters are completely one-dimensional. The actors do their best Karl Urban makes a serviceable effort as the tight-lipped John Grimm, the nameless marine of the game. The best in the cast is Rosamund Pike who comes from a British stage background and made an impressive appearance in the James Bond film Die Another Day (2002). Even she is defeated by the one-dimensionality of the characters all her role requires her to do is spout techno-babble and wear tops that leave her nipples prominently exposed throughout. Wrestler Dwayne Johnson alias The Rock appears to have taken some more acting lessons since the first lead role that one saw him in The Scorpion King (2002) but is hamstrung by hard-to-buy character twists that require him to suddenly out-of-the-blue turn psychotic and then become the nemesis of the show for the climactic showdown.
All in all, Doom is a disappointing adaptation of the game. The film had a foolproof scenario to work with all it needed to do was to provide lots of violence and shooting but the filmmakers only seem to come up with a damp squib of a movie that barely even rattles the pulse.