The filming of such a complex and vaunted book was a daunting task that found the better of many. Roger Corman owned the rights at one point (one shudders to imagine what the film would have emerged like on a typical Corman budget). The most interesting of the planned productions was one that Alejandro Jodorowski, the cultish director of the bizarre likes of El Topo (1970), The Holy Mountain (1975) and Santa Sangre (1989), attempted to mount in 1976. This would have included such tantalising novelties as H.R. Giger, Chris Foss and Jean Moebius Giraud designing the look of the various worlds; Dan OBannon, later the screenwriter of Alien (1979), on special effects; a score from Pink Floyd; and such unique casting as Orson Welles as Baron Harkonnen, Mick Jagger as Feyd-Rautha and Salvador Dali in the role of the Emperor. The Alejandro Jodorowsky Dune is one that lives in legend stories of it seem totally wild. Jodorowsky would have used the book only as a loose text and would have varied considerably from Frank Herbert Jodorowskys Emperor was a madman who lived in a palace of gold at the centre of the galaxy with an exact robot duplicate; the film would have focused on the alchemical/mystical nature of Pauls spice experience and the Bene Gesserit religion; and would have ended with Pauls death and the transubstantiation of Arrakis into a force of consciousness that moves through the universe. Alas, Jodorowsky never found the funding for his idiosyncratic adaptation. There was a fascinating documentary made about this never-made version with Jodorowskys Dune (2013).
Dino De Laurentiis, the infamous producer of King Kong (1976) and Flash Gordon (1980), then bought the rights to Dune. De Laurentiis tried to mount a production with Ridley Scott, director of Alien and Blade Runner (1982), for a time then finally succeeded with David Lynch. At that point, David Lynch was a relative unknown who had made the midnight cult favourite Eraserhead (1977) and the more mainstream, critically acclaimed The Elephant Man (1980), which had had him nominated for a Best Director Academy Award. Following Dune, David Lynch would of course go onto make the likes of Blue Velvet (1986) also for Dino De Laurentiis, Wild at Heart (1990), Lost Highway (1997), The Straight Story (1999), Mulholland Dr. (2001), Inland Empire (2006) and the cult tv series Twin Peaks (1990-1) and its two theatrical spinoffs, Twin Peaks (1990) and Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me (1992), and make a name as one of the cultiest, most bizarre directors at work today. Dune was David Lynchs first and last brush with big-budget studio-type film-making and Lynch has since publicly disowned the film.
All fans of the book lambasted the film when it appeared. Cult books tend not to make for successful films as they are viewed by a body of fans who are so familiar with the story they get finicky when small details are changed or their conception of the characters are not followed the way they think they should be. To get it over and done with, no, the film is not a successful adaptation of the book by a wide margin. Dune was a film caught in an unenviable position of being far too complex and challenging a story for audiences who were unfamiliar with the book to understand and invariably disappointing for those who had. The problem was not David Lynchs own he had originally envisioned a three hour plus epic but faced Universal who demanded that the final print only be two-and-a-half hours long. Lynch did not have Final Cut on the film and as a result was forced to sacrifice large sections of material that had been shot in order to bring the finished film in under the mandated time. Nevertheless, Dune remains a fascinating, even at times brilliant film. Certainly, it is not the disaster that David Lynch and many fans seem to think it is.
The first two thirds of the film is very faithful to the book. David Lynch does an excellent job of capturing all the intergalactic in-politicking and Frank Herberts games within games. However, it is the second half that disappoints. Lynch has cut out almost all the portrait of the Fremen and much of the messianic mysticism. The political holy war is reduced to a few brief war scenes. We, for instance, have no idea why the Fremen accept Paul Atreides as their messiah. Most disappointing, there is none of the fascinating immersion in a culture centred around desert survival and the scarcity of water that was one of the most interesting parts of the book. (There is a re-edited version that aired on tv in 1988 and is available on DVD, which contains some 40 minutes of footage unseen in the theatrical release. However, David Lynch objected to this version and substituted the generic Directors Guild pseudonym Allan Smithee in lieu of his own). The films biggest miscalculation on the book may well be the ending. Lynch follows the book with the fate of the empire being decided in a duel between Paul and Feyd-Rautha but then throws in a mystical eucatastrophe where Pauls political triumph is seemingly echoed by the entire planet, which seems to cheer him on by miraculously raining. It is a banal and unnecessary ending.
However, David Lynch may be incapable of making an entirely bad film. Dune tends to work best when Lynch gets the opportunity to conduct some freewheeling improvisations on Frank Herbert. The scenes Lynch seems to have the most relish for are the Harkonnen scenes. In the book, Frank Herbert merely left one with the suggestion that the Baron had paedophile tastes, but Lynch crafts the Harkonnen scenes with a much greater degree of grotesquerie than that. We are introduced to the Harkonnens in one wonderfully bizarre scene where Kenneth McMillans Baron sits being injected in his hideous facial sores by attendants in plastic macs, mirrorshades and sewn-shut cabbage ears, while Paul Smith sits drinking cocktails of squelched up insects, before the Baron rips out the throat of a hermaphroditic character and goes flying off through the open roof in his inflated longjohns maniacally laughing. There is a later thoroughly demented scene on Arrakis with Stings appearance, clad only in leather jockstrap and evilly smiling, while the Baron flies around a jet of steam at high-speed, all to the accompaniment of a wailing organ played by Eraserhead hero Jack Nance. All of which serves to add to a compulsively weird fascination.
Dune had a then-impressive budget in the neighbourhood of $40 million and it certainly shows up stunningly on screen. Dune was one of the few films in the post-Star Wars (1977), post-Alien, post-Mad Max 2 (1981) era to break away from the rundown technology look. Tony Masters creates a universe of art deco retro-futurism, filled with rococo technology of steam carriages or communications devices that look like old radio microphones. Each of the worlds comes with a distinctive look Caladan all brooding in deep woods, the fluted gilt piping of the Emperors palace, to the cavernous New Wave industrial nightmare world of the Harkonnen Giedi Prime. Dune is one of the most imaginatively designed of all science-fiction films.
The special effects are stunning. Carlo Rambaldi creates Frank Herberts sandworms with spectacular regard. The first appearance of a worm bursting out of the sand, crushing a spice miner in its jaws is dazzling. The climactic battle with Paul leading the Fremen into battle riding aboard hundreds of the giant sandworms takes the breath away in terms of scale. The most beautiful scene in the film again one where David Lynch freely improvises on Frank Herbert is the space travel sequence where we first follow tiny ships up off the planet and watch as they are dwarfed in scale as they enter the gilted door of giant orbiting cylinder and then once inside the giant spermatozoid Navigator moves up out of the cavernous gloom and warps the stars about it. It is a spectacularly beautiful moment of pure science-fictional beauty.
David Lynch also arraigns an impressively large cast. He casts a number of the actors he regularly works with Freddie Jones, Everett McGill, Dean Stockwell, and of course Eraserheads hero Jack Nance who appeared in all of David Lynchs films until his death in 1996. (Lynch himself can be spotted in a brief cameo as one of the workers on the spice miner that is attacked by the sandworm). Kyle MacLachlan appears in the first of several distinctive and unique collaborations he would make with Lynch. Dune was also Kyle MacLachlans film debut and he brings his customary assured handsomeness to the role. The beautifully elegant Francesca Annis is well cast as Pauls mother. Eight year-old Alicia Witt has strikingly evil presence as Pauls younger sister Alia. [Witt would later gain attention as an adult actress with a recurring role as Cybill Shepherds daughter in the sitcom Cybill (1995-8) and in the slasher film Urban Legend (1998)].
The book was later remade as Dune (2000), a tv mini-series made by director-writer John Harrison for The Sci-Fi Channel. This is a fine version and gives the book a much more substantial airing than this film does. The two make for interesting comparison. The mini-series has the greater running time to treat the book with much more scope and the severely curtailed Fremen scenes and messianic mysticism gets a much more complete airing here. The mini-series made an admirable depiction of Arrakis on its modest budget; on the other hand, the film version definitely has the more epic feel. Also the perversity that David Lynch invested the Harkonnens with makes for a much more interesting set of villains Harrison never took the mini-series in that direction and Ian McNeices Baron seems decidedly wimpy. Harrison later wrote a further tv mini-series Children of Dune (2003), which adapted Frank Herberts second and third books in the series, Dune Messiah and Children of Dune. A further cinematic Dune remake has been posited for the 2010s first by director Peter Berg and Pierre Morel.
David Lynchs other films are Eraserhead (1977), The Elephant Man (1980), Blue Velvet (1986), Twin Peaks (1990), Wild at Heart (1990), Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me (1992), Lost Highway (1997), The Straight Story (1999), Mulholland Dr. (2001) and Inland Empire (2006). Lynch also created and directed many episodes of the cult tv series Twin Peaks (1990-1, 2017). Lynch has also produced other genre films such as The Cabinet of Dr Ramirez (1991), Nadja (1994), Surveillance (2008), My Son, My Son, What Have Ye Done (2009) and Black and White in Colors (2010), as well as two short-lived surrealist tv series with On the Air (1992) and Hotel Room (1993). Lynch (2007) and David Lynch: The Art Life (2016) are documentaries about Lynch.