Gattacas position on the genetic engineering debate is a conservative one. This is surely made clear from the poster for the film, which bears the legend There is no gene for the human spirit. In opting for such, Gattaca buys into the black-and-white straw arguments that the conservative side of the genetics debate has eked out for itself that any of the potential gains to be made from genetic engineering the elimination of inherited diseases is outweighed by an elusive and undefined quality known as the human spirit. In any other name, the old credo: If man was meant to fly hed have been born with wings.
In Gattacas favour, it is not about the arguments for and against genetic engineering as much as it is a What If? portrait of a society where class position and status is based on ones genes. Once the plot settles in, Gattaca turns out to be a surprisingly worthwhile film. The story is tight and wound into an impressive thriller. The dialogue is equally sharply polished usually in dystopias you expect the script to merely offer up ideological speeches. Considerable ingenuity has been placed into thinking out how law enforcement might work in such a society based on genetic class and even more into thinking out the steps a criminal might have to go to get around such. Stars Ethan Hawke and especially Uma Thurman seem slightly blank but Jude Law gives a performance that has an appealingly acerbic bite as the wheelchair-ridden genetic benefactor.
Director Andrew Niccol crafts it all with a cool, sophisticated elegance. Gattaca was made on a slim budget and Niccol creates an effectively futuristic vision simply by shooting modern building interiors in a shadowless light. All the colour has been washed out of the frame so that the film appears to be shot in a virtual sepia-tone. The effect creates a future that conveys a cool sophistication with a subtle air of disquiet.
Andrew Niccol is shaping up as a highly promising genre talent. He next went onto write the script for the excellent The Truman Show (1998) about a man who discovers his entire life is set up for tv cameras. Niccols second directorial outing was S1m0ne (2002), a comedy about a virtual Hollywood actress, although this failed to realise the possibilities Niccol showed in either Gattaca or The Truman Show. However, Niccol bounced back with his third directorial outing Lord of War (2005), a bitingly black comedy about the international arms trade. He has also made a similar dystopian film with the also excellent In Time (2011); the adaptation of Stephenie Meyers The Host (2013) about alien body snatchers; Good Kill (2014) about modern drone warfare; and Anon (2018) set in a mass-surveillance future.
(Winner in this sites Top 10 Films of 1997 list. Nominee for Best Director (Andrew Niccol), Best Original Screenplay, Best Supporting Actor (Jude Law), Best Cinematography and Best Music at this sites Best of 1997 Awards).