ON THE COMET
With On the Comet, Karel Zeman returns to Jules Verne for the third time, adapting one of Vernes less well-known novels Hector Servadac (1877), also known in English under a variety of different titles including Off on a Comet and Career of a Comet. The original novel concerns thirty-six people near Gibraltar who are swept up during the passby of a comet and find themselves in a strange land that operates by very different laws of physics as the comet travels through the Solar System. The same Jules Verne novel has also previously been filmed on the cheap, with the addition of stock dinosaur footage, as the English-language Valley of the Dragons (1961).
Jules Verne was very much in vogue during the 1950s and 60s following the success of Disneys 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea (1954). This brought a spate of Verne adaptations that included the likes of From the Earth to the Moon (1958), Journey to the Center of the Earth (1959), Master of the World (1961), Mysterious Island (1961), Five Weeks in a Balloon (1962), In Search of the Castaways (1962), Jules Vernes Rocket to the Moon/Blast Off/Those Fantastic Flying Fools (1967), The Light at the Edge of the World (1971) and The Mysterious Island of Captain Nemo (1972). As the cycle wound on, many of the efforts began to abandon scrupulous faithfulness to Vernes book and take on a broadly slapstick and buffoonish tone. The genre had tapered off by the 1970s, which could well be why On the Comet has not been widely seen in English-language release.
I really liked Karel Zemans first Jules Verne adaptation The Fabulous World of Jules Verne with its replication of the original Victorian-era lithographs in a visually extraordinary mix of animation and live-action such that you never knew what was what. I was hoping that he would do the same here but ended up being disappointed. Certainly, the opening scenes where Zeman has made an attempt to mock much of the film up with the look of Victorian-era sepia tone photographs and postcards do head back in this direction. On the other hand, this never plays out that imaginatively we get a few scenes of ships and the comet and some colour tinted landscapes in which Zeman plays around with effects where you are not sure what is what but the degree of animation/live-action mix is much lesser here. The dinosaur effects are passable, the comet effects slightly less so.
The Jules Verne novel is taken up by a depiction of the partys survival aboard the comet and exploration of its different physical conditions. Karel Zeman keeps faith with that somewhat. The parties never do much to explore the world they are on. We also get the addition of dinosaurs, which are not present in the Verne novel. Mostly the film concerns itself with the comic runnings around and interactions between the French, Spanish, British and Bedouin, as well as love interest Magda Vasaryova (a character not present in the book) and her efforts to avoid being recaptured by the gunrunners. There is a mild amusement to the scene where the French decide their cannons and guns are useless and throw them over the side of the fort (something hard to believe military would order) to be replaced by tin pots on sticks to drive the dinosaurs away, only for the guns to be recovered by other parties who promptly take the opportunity to raid the fort. Here you get the impression that Zeman has taken on board too much of the influence of the English-language Verne adaptations of the 1960s and their pitching everything to the broadly comedic. The film also arrives at a confusing ending that seems to suggest that everything that happened was a dream being had by Emil Horvath.