The Science Fiction, Horror and Fantasy Film Review
Reviews
All Titles
· A – B · C – D
· E – F · G – H
· I – K · L – M
· N – O · P – R
· S – T · U – Z
Sections
Science-Fiction
· A – D · E – K
· L – Q · R – Z
Horror
· A – D · E – K
· L – Q · R – Z
Fantasy
· A – D · E – K
· L – Q · R – Z
New
· Most Recent Additions
Annual Best and Worst
· 2011 · 2010
· 2009 · 2008
· 2007 · 2006
· 2005 · 2004
· 2003 · 2002
· 2001 · 2000
· 1999 · 1998
· 1997 · 1996
· 1995 · 1994
Contact
· Contact This Site
Link to This Page With



    Q PLANES
    aka
    CLOUDS OVER EUROPE
    Rating

     
    UK. 1939.
    Director – Tim Whelan, Screenplay – Ian Dalrymple, Story – Jack Whittingham, Brock Williams & Arthur Wimperis, Producer – Irving Asher, Photography (b&w) – Harry Stradling, Music Supervisor – Muir Mathieson, Supervising Art Director – Vincent Korda. Production Company – Harefield/London.
    Cast:
    Ralph Richardson (Major Charles Hammond), Laurence Olivier (Tony McVane), Valerie Hobson (Kay Lawrence), George Merritt (Barrett), George Curzon (Jenkins), George Butler (Air Marshall Gosport), Sandra Storme (Daphne)
     

     
    Plot: Planes carrying top secret machine parts are going missing at sea. In truth they being brought down and their crews taken prisoner by an enemy ship that is using a raygun that blows out the plane’s motor and forces it to crashland. Eccentric British Secret Service agent Major Charles Hammond and pilot Tony McVane team up to get to the bottom of the mystery.
     

     
    On the level of plot description, this seems a story that has been dragged from the pages of Hugo Gernsback’s Air Wonder Stories or any British boy’s magazine – it could easily have been a Biggles adventure. But director Tim Whelan and in particular star Ralph Richardson conspire to turn it into a completely different film and if anything it ends up becoming more of a frothy British drawing room stage comedy than it is ever an air adventure story. The results turn out as something really quite eccentric. Ralph Richardson makes a quite a bizarre comic character, charging through the film with a kind of dapper comic certainty. There are some quite funny bits with him picking carrots up on the end of his umbrella; deciding to cook stews to help himself think; opening a wardrobe that is filled with identical bowler hats then eventually absently choosing the same hat he gave his manservant to hold; and a running gag about him continually having to postpone his plans with girlfriend Sandra Storme and not allowing her the opportunity to say what she wants (which at the end turns out to be that she has married another man). A very young Laurence Olivier plays the handsome straight-man.

    At least amid all the eccentricity the detective story isn’t neglected and buzzes along quite well. Although the actual science-fictional content for which the film is often listed in guides – a mysterious motor-destroying ray beam – is minimal. And there are some annoying lapses – such as the story never telling us why the unnamed foreign power wishes to capture British airmen and planes.
     


    Copyright Richard Scheib 1999-2012