Up until this point, Kurt Neumann, a German immigrant who had been directing since the 1930s, had made a series of routine Westerns, B-movie thrillers, Tarzan films and musicals. Indeed, the film that Neumann would be most well known for was his last The Fly (1958). (See below for Kurt Neumanns other genre films). Here for the first time, Neumann also writes the films screenplay. What surprises one about an (up until then) otherwise undistinguished director and a film that was made on the quick is that Neumann does a fine job on script. The science during the spaceflight is surprisingly accurate for the most part. Moreover, Neumann creates some wonderfully poetic turns of phrase when it comes to describing the journey through space: the wind between worlds, No-ones ever seen the light reflected from a dead world before and Osa Massens description of her one and only romance the water black like cold coffee, the moonlight like flecks of cream floating on it. Neumann even throws in sly jokes: Down on the ranch I used to throw a thousand pound steer over my shoulder every morning, You sure that wasnt a little bull you were throwing?
Dramatically, Rocketship X-M is actually a more interesting film than Destination Moon turned out to be. Kurt Neumann takes care to create characters whereas Destination Moon was centred around self-contained dramatic and special effects set pieces without any real human resonance. Of course, the one thing that Destination Moon had over Rocketship X-M was colour and a top-notch budget that allowed it some of the best special effects available in the era. Rocketship X-M is also much less interesting on the directorial level. Kurt Neumanns set-ups are frequently static and he rarely ever relies on external special effects. (The shots through the capsule windows are modestly effective as are some of the mattes, although the model effects vary). The red-tinted scenes and the desert locations do a surprisingly convincing job of evoking the Martian surface.
What is perhaps surprising is the films lack of interest in exploring the Martian city all that is seen of it is it in the distance, a couple of artefacts and the degenerated Martian survivors. This was very much indicative of depictions of space exploration in subsequent 1950s science-fiction. Destination Moon started the science-fiction boom off with an enormously optimistic imaginative bound a call to go forth and conquer the Moon but just when the genre seemed on the verge of leaping out to conquer other worlds, suddenly all that space travellers seemed to find was the spectre of atomic warfare or civilisations that had destroyed themselves due their own hubris or warlike ways. This pessimism came to seriously undercut the imaginative drive outward and overshadow science-fiction over the next twelve years see other films of the era like This Island Earth (1955), Forbidden Planet (1956) and First Spaceship on Venus (1959).
Rocketship X-M is also amusing to compare to the real Moon landing nearly two decades later here the existence of the Moon rocket is only announced to journalists fifteen minutes before it is due to launch and demonstrated by crude chalk drawings on a blackboard. The medical tests the astronauts undergo consist of everybody sitting around in an office having their blood pressure taken. Unlike the real Moon mission, the film here has a woman aboard from the start, something the US space programme did not achieve until nearly two decades after the Moon landing. That said, the film does have a typically 1950s condescension towards her presence with much talk about how achieving professional standing means that she has become emotionally cut off.
In the original cinematic release of the film, the Martian scenes were tinted red, but most modern prints of the film have reverted this to black-and-white. In 1978, film distributor/collector Wade Williams brought up rights to Rocketship X-M and shot several new special effects sequences and scenes on the Martian surface. This version was seen on video for a number of years but subsequent releases have replaced these with the original effects scenes.
Kurt Neumanns other genre films are: several of the Johnny Weissmuller Tarzan films Tarzan and the Amazons (1945), Tarzan and the Leopard Man (1946) and Tarzan and the Huntress (1947) and one with Lex Barker Tarzan and the She-Devil (1953); the Arabian Nights fantasy Son of Ali Baba (1952); the mad scientist cheapie She Devil (1957); the interesting Kronos (1957) about an alien energy-devouring machine; and the classic monster movie The Fly (1958).