The opening chapter Superman Comes to Earth does a fine job of encapsulating the essence of the Superman origin story and faithfully telling it the way it existed in the Golden Age Krypton as a world of Grecian idealism, Jor-els warnings being ignored by the council, the launch of the rocket and the infants adoption by the Kents and being raised to manhood. (About the only point of difference is Clark Kents stepfather being named Eben rather than the canonical Jonathan, although it should be noted that the Kent backstory was never properly fleshed out in the comic-books until 1948 and Kent Sr did not receive the name Jonathan until 1950). All the essential aspects of the origin story are covered, setting the second chapter up to deal with the first appearance of Superman.
On the other hand, the first appearance of Kirk Alyn as Superman is slightly underwhelming. One must remember that one is watching the serial in 2012 as opposed to 1948 and viewing it through the filter of not only numerous other Superman films and tv series, all being made with much higher budgets, but an entire industry of superhero films that have pushed the boundaries of on-screen superheroics about as far as it is possible to take them. You are unable to stop comparing the low horizons the superheroics here operate on with what has come since. Things would have been vastly different for audiences back in 1948. Here Supermans first exploit is to jump out and stop a runaway train. This is not a bad exploit for Superman they even included a variant of it in the first Christopher Reeve film Superman (1978). However, rather than flying in and saving the day, Kirk Alyn merely changes behind a bush then runs out from behind in Superman costume. Where Christopher Reeves Superman went to the extent of using his body as a rail and allowing the train to cross it, Alyn merely bends the rail into place then leaves the scene.
The biggest disappointment is the cheap corner-cutting of the special effects whenever Superman takes to the air, he becomes represented by an animated figure (courtesy of the Fleischer studio). Evidently animation was cheaper than the cost of any optical or physical wire effects to depict Kirk Alyn taking off and landing. Even things such as the bullets that bounce off Supermans chest or the images of him bursting through a rock wall have been animated. Not merely satisfied with cutting corners by animating Supermans flight, some of the same flying shots have also been reused in different chapters. There are a couple of superheroic feats that come off reasonably well one where Superman catches a missile fired at him in his hand and throws it back at the henchmen; and where Kirk Alyn flies down and stands in front of and stops an oncoming train (even though the rear-projection work of the train is obvious).
Up until the 1970s and the point of the Christopher Reeve Superman, filmed superheroes always had an uncertainty when it came to allowing them to be superheroes. The plots in the other comic-book adapted serials such as Adventures of Captain Marvel (1941), Batman (1943), The Phantom (1943), Captain America (1944) and tv shows such as Adventures of Superman (1952-8), The Six Million Dollar Man (1973-8), The Amazing Spiderman (1977-9), The New Original Wonder Woman (1976-9) and The Incredible Hulk (1977-81) only ever seemed to pit the superheroes against mundane criminals rather than super-villains and substituted world saving heroics with routine cop show plots. (In the case of the wartime serials, the superheroes were frequently co-opted into the fights against Axis powers). The sole exception might be tvs Batman (1966-8) but there the super-villains were clearly intended in a non-serious way.
The Spider Lady could have made for a worthy super-villain but the serial fails to write her in any interesting way she is simply a mob boss who wears an evening gown. Apart from one chapter, she remains in her lair for the duration, only relaying orders to lackeys by radio. The writers even fail to make anything of her being a Spider Lady in the same way that characters like Batman, Spider-Man and Cat Woman are given costuming and powers based around their particular animal motifs. About the sole larger than life touch is her having a wall-sized electrified web in her lair, which is good for disposing of recalcitrant lackeys and pinning Lois to in one cliffhanger. Carol Forman gives a performance that fails to vamp the part up in any interesting way either.
The plot is along the lines of a typical serial where the drama is extruded out via races to obtain pieces of gadgetry, formulas or essential chemicals needed to make the central McGuffin device work. (This is the Relativity Reducer Ray, although it is never clear what it actually does something about a device to focus cosmic rays and project them long distance). To its credit, the serial does introduce Kryptonite part way in and various episodes centre around The Spider Lady trying to lay her hands on it to defeat Superman. The script does conduct a number of considerable cheats at various points. In one scene, one of the hoods tells the Spider Lady theres a scientific way to make him [scientist Herbert Rawlinson] obey our every command and then in the next scene we see that they have so reprogrammed him via some type of mind control. Alas, the means whereby this is done have been entirely omitted, which makes for sloppy sleight-of-hand plotting. The other cheat might be the climactic scenes where Superman finally ventures into the Spider Ladys lair but is defeated by her Kryptonite only to reveal a few minutes later that he has been playing possum, having had the foresight to line his costume with lead.
The serial does nothing particularly outstanding with any of its cliffhangers. The sole exceptions to this might be one scene where Jimmy Olsen hides in a crate in the back of a truck, only for the hoods to find him there and pepper the crate with machine-gun bullets and another sequence where Perry White engages in a great room-wrecking fistfight with a hood in his office and is punched straight out the window to his apparent death.
Kirk Alyn makes for a passable Superman his body language is somewhat weak but he plays the part with a reasonable certainty and an imperturbable cheer. He does okay, although never seems to inflate the role with the larger than life heroism of a George Reeves or the sincerity of a Christopher Reeve. What must be said is that Alyn does undergo a remarkable chameleon shift in switching between the roles of Superman and Clark Kent and manages to nail the gee shucks milquetoast nature and dull straightness of Clark perfectly. (One of the oddities of the dual roles is that when Kirk Alyn dons the hat, glasses and double-breasted suit as Clark Kent, it makes him look Alyns natural 61 height, whereas in the Superman costume Alyn comes out physically more puny and only about 56 in height). One of the best pieces of casting is Noel Neills Lois Lane. Neill gives the part just the right degree of peppery determination and feistiness that it makes the character of Lois and her relationship with Clark work as it should. Indeed, the relationship between the two of them here is possibly the one occasion where film and tv manage to capture the Clark-Lois-Superman triangle the way the Golden and Silver Age Superman comics wrote it better than any other.
Kirk Alyn, Noel Neill, Tommy Bond and Pierre Watkin all returned in a sequel Atom Man vs Superman (1950), which introduced the first screen appearance of Lex Luthor. Noel Neill was also reappeared as Lois Lane, replacing Phyllis Coates in the role, from the second season onwards in the classic tv series Adventures of Superman (1952-8) with George Reeves. Both Kirk Alyn and Noel Neill made cameo appearances as Lois Lanes parents in the first Christopher Reeve Superman film. These were cut from the original print, apart from one minor scene with a couple and child looking out the window of the train where it is never made clear who they are, but this is restored in extended versions of the film. Kirk Alyn passed away in 1999 but Noel Neill makes a further appearance as the aging dowager that Lex Luthor rips off in Bryan Singers Superman Returns (2006).
Other versions of the Superman legend are:- seventeen Superman animated shorts produced by Fleischer Studios between 1941 and 1943; the low-budget feature film Superman and the Mole-Men (1951), which became the basis of the long-running tv series Adventures of Superman (1952-8) starring George Reeves; the film Superman (1978) starring Christopher Reeve, which led to three sequels with Superman II (1980), Superman III (1983), Superman IV: The Quest for Peace (1987), as well as spinoffs like Supergirl (1984) and tvs Superboy (1988-91); Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman (1993-7), a popular tv series that focused more on the love triangle relationship between Clark/Superman (Dean Cain) and Lois Lane (Teri Hatcher); the excellent animated series Superman (1996-2000) where the superheroic exploits were rendered in a beautifully stylised Art Deco milieu; several spinoff films from the animated series with Superman: The Last Son of Krypton (1996), The Batman Superman Movie: Worlds Finest (1998), Superman: Brainiac Attacks (2006), Superman: Doomsday (2007), Superman/Batman: Public Enemies (2009), Superman/Batman: Apocalypse (2010), All-Star Superman (2011), Superman vs. The Elite (2012) and Superman Unbound (2013), while Superman also appears in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns Part II (2013) and as one of line-up of DC superheroes in the same creative teams Justice League/Justice League Unlimited (2001-6) and its film spinoffs Justice League: The New Frontier (2008), Justice League: Crisis on Two Earths (2010), Justice League: Doom (2012), Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox (2013), Justice League: War (2014), Justice League: Throne of Atlantis (2015), Justice League: Gods and Monsters (2015), Justice League vs Teen Titans (2016) and Justice League Dark (2017), as well as in Legion of Superheroes (2006-8) from a different creative team, while Young Justice (2010-3) features Superboy, a clone of Superman, as a regular character; the tv series Smallville (2001-11) played by Tom Welling, which concerns Supermans teen years; Bryan Singers follow-up to the Christopher Reeve films Superman Returns (2006) starring Brandon Routh; Superman II: The Richard Donner Cut (2006), Richard Donners edit of his original intended vision of Superman II, which had been subject to much in-fighting with the producers; and Zack Snyders reboot Man of Steel (2013) starring Henry Cavill and its follow-ups, the DC superhero team-ups Batman V Superman: Dawn of Justice (2016) and Justice League (2017); the tv series Supergirl (2015 ) starring Melissa Benoist with appearances from Tyler Hoechlin as Superman; and the prequel tv series Krypton (2018 ). Superman also turns up as an animated character in The Lego Movie (2014). Also of interest is The Death of Superman Lives: What Happened? (2015), a documentary about the aborted Tim Burton-Nicolas Cage Superman film of the late 1990s.