The Terminator saga did not end there. James Cameron declined to be involved with the series after that point but his producer/former wife Gale Ann Hurd went onto produce the disappointingly lame Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines (2003), which had Arnold Schwarzenegger and a big budget but little else, least of all conviction. There was also the tv series Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles (2008-9), which ended up being half a good series, surmounting a bland first season that mostly centred around blowing up and shooting at things to create some occasionally quite good science-fiction stories by the time of its cancellation (which inauspiciously came a month before Terminator Salvation premiered).
I did not have high hopes for Terminator Salvation, especially in that the script came from John Brancato and Michael Ferris, the same duo who wrote the at-times risible Rise of the Machines. Most of all, what made ones not-very-high hopes sink was the assignment of the directorial chair to McG. It is probably an unwritten rule of thumb that any director who goes by a single name is someone who is full of their own self importance and whose work invariably collapses into abject pretension other guilty directorial offenders being Kaos of Ballistic: Ecks vs Sever (2002) fame and Pitof of Catwoman (2004) notoriety, which was also notedly written by Brancato and Ferris. The same one-name truism can probably extend to acting and music indeed, Terminator Salvation comes with the ill portent of no less than three single-named individuals attached including also Common and Jadagrace.
McG, or to give him the less pretentious birth name of Joseph McGinty Nichol, emerged as a music video director in the 1990s. He suddenly became a hot Hollywood name on the basis of his first film Charlies Angels (2000), which was a hit but also an empty-headed film that stripmined a tv series brand name and reconceived it as some kind of Spice Girls action movie built around a series of slickly revved-up action moves that frequently toppled over into unintentional parody. While the public seemed to like Charlies Angels, most of them switched off when it came to McG offering more of the same in Charlies Angels: Full Throttle (2003). Though he has gained a high profile Hollywood name and been associated with a number of other projects, including at one point what emerged as Superman Returns (2006), planned remakes of Blade Runner (1982), Revenge of the Nerds (1984) and a version of 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea, McG has only directed one other film up to that point the bland We Are Marshall (2006) although he would subsequently go onto make the spy romcom This Means War (2012), the okay spy action/comedy 3 Days to Kill (2014) and the horror film The Babysitter (2017). Indeed, McG seems to have spent most of his time between Charlies Angels and Terminator Salvation lending his name as producer to various tv series, including Fastlane (2002-3), The Mountain (2004-5), Human Target (2010-11), Nikita (2010-3) and the huge hits of The O.C. (2003-7), Supernatural (2005 ) and Chuck (2007-12), as well as the absurd videogame horror film Stay Alive (2006) and the Stephen King adaptation Mercy (2014).
Terminator Salvation seemed to befall incredible run of bad luck through shooting the script underwent numerous rewrites and even then the ending had to be changed after the script that originally ended with John Connor transformed into a cyborg was leaked online; effects creator Stan Winston died in the midst of production; and then there was the damaging leak of a four-minute audio clip of Christian Bales rampaging temper tantrum against cinematographer Shane Hurlbut for accidentally walking into a shot; as well as the various producers engaged in legal fighting with one another before the film opened. The production did not exactly get James Camerons blessing, despite much claim whether it did or not beforehand, although this eventually only coalesced to Cameron simply wishing McG well and deciding not to prejudge the film before he saw it. (Ominously nobody broadcast Camerons views subsequent to the films release).
I am happy to confess that my expectations of a McG directed Terminator film did not come out as badly as I imagined they might. In fact, Terminator Salvation is a reasonably watchable film and by no means the disaster that advance US reviews and lower-than-expected box-office returns had it as. Terminator 2 more than admirably followed the dictum of a good sequel in that it expanded on its predecessor, taking it to a whole new level in terms of special effects/action spectacle and introducing the ingenious concept of the shape-changing liquid metal T-1000. Terminator 3 failed miserably at taking a similar quantum leap, producing only B-budget effects and failing to come up with anything to top the T-1000. This is not an omission that Terminator Salvation is guilty of however. The design and effects team give us an amazing new series of Terminators, including giant size robots Terminators that look like they have stepped out of Transformers (2007), as well as an army of skeletal androids, robotic snakes and some nifty looking terminator motorcycle units.
There is very much the sense that McG is trying to make Terminator Salvation bigger-than-big and trying to out-scale Terminator 2. In the first few scenes, we have the entry into an underground complex and its massive destruction in an atomic explosion, followed by Christian Bale crashing in a helicopter and then improbably diving into an ocean that seems about to transform into a storm a la The Perfect Storm (2000) to meet with his superiors. The films showcapper is a foot-to-the-pedal sequence about twenty-five minutes in where McG goes for broke. It is a sequence that starts with the introduction of the giant Transformer Terminator, effortlessly massacring the rebels at the gas station, only for Sam Worthington, Anton Yelchin and Jadagrace to escape in a petrol tanker, dumping its payload in an attempt to blow the Transformer up. The sequence doesnt end there but continues with the eminently WTF moment when the Transformer ejects the motorcycle Terminators from its ankle struts and we segue into a breathlessly paced sequence as the humans attempt to demolish these using a wrecking ball while racing along a highway at high speed. The sequence keeps escalating in scale until we have the Transformer blasting apart a bridge, Anton Yelchin snatched up and Sam Worthington battling around the outside of a Hunter-Seeker in mid-air before resistance fighter planes fly into the attack. It is a sequence filled with breathless adrenalin, where McG keeps upping the scale of action and never allowing the heroes a moments respite. It is the best sequence in the film and not even the climax manages to top this.
The central focus of the plot is the creation of a new form of Terminator that is a part-human cyborg and does not know of its mechanised nature shades of Philip K. Dick or tvs Battlestar Galactica (2003-9). It may seem slightly incredulous that someone with mechanical parts under their skin might not ever notice such like about surely the first time they cut themselves or underwent a medical exam. And while the character of Marcus Wright is a fascinating new addition to the series, the film never manages to do much more than delve into a few Philip K. Dickian cliches and debate whether the resistance should kill him or not, before having Sam Worthington tear out his chip and reclaim his humanity. My main beef here is that the main surprise about Sam Worthington being a machine was given away by the films trailer. When he turns up in the prologue as an executed prisoner whose body is bought up by Skynet and then later as someone wandering the post-holocaust landscape with no idea of where he is, the films one big surprise has been signalled all too clearly. Which is a shame as this could have emerged as a considerable jolt mid-film had the production team been a little more judicious about protecting their surprises.
Outside of that, the script cycles through variants on the plot arcs patented by the first two Terminator films. Where Terminator 2 has John Connor befriending and teaching a Terminator the meaning of humanity, this has John cautiously trusting and finding the human inside a half-human Terminator. Where Terminator 2 has people trying to save the youthful John Connor and protect the future, this has John trying to save the youthful Kyle Reese and protect the causal loop that led to his own birth. (There does seem a big continuity hole here in that clearly we are at a point on the timeline when the machines have not yet invented time travel and have only just started coating the machines with flesh skins, so how do they know that John Connor will grow into the resistance leader and of the future importance of Kyle Reese?). To its credit, the film does at least abandon the time travel plots of Terminators coming back to the present to eliminate the Connors that were used by all the other films and tv series and ventures into new and different territory to tell the potentially interesting story of the resistance.
Terminator Salvation also comes mired in fannish obeisance. There are numerous quotes of familiar lines from the rest of the series Come with me if you want to live and Ill be back while Christian Bales end voiceover is a slightly rewritten version of Linda Hamiltons epilogue at the end of Terminator 2. There is even a version of the original Arnold Schwarzenegger Terminator that turns up where Schwarzeneggers face has been digitised and composited onto the shoulders of a bodybuilder.
Yet, while Terminator Salvation does compete with Terminator 2 in terms of upping the scale of the action and providing a new arsenal of Terminators, what it ultimately lacks is the humanist poetry and depths of character that James Cameron managed to imbue his films with. The end with the machine learning the notion of heart as Sam Worthington sacrifices his heart to save Christian Bale is a metaphor that is clunky and overripe to an almost laughable extreme. Contrast that to the beautifully written scenes in Terminator 2 when Linda Hamilton observes The Terminator becoming a father substitute to John and its discovering of a morality. That the film goes out merely parroting the haunting voiceover close to Terminator 2 rather than come up with one of its own, shows a Terminator film that ultimately stands too slavishly in the shadow of its predecessors.
A further sequel was made with the disastrous Terminator Genisys (2015).
(Nominee for Best Special Effects and Best Makeup Effects at this sites Best of 2009 Awards).